George Orwell has written: "He who controls the past controls the future." Some of the most distinguished American historians are working hard to control the past by proving, to state it simply, that the United States did not win the Cold War. Why? So that when our children and their children study post-World War II history they will never know that the capitalist democracies, led by our country, saved the world from what could have been conquest by a communist totalitarian dictatorship based on Marxist socialist dogmas. And, perhaps even more to the point, they will never know that an overwhelmingly popular two-term president, Ronald Reagan, presided over the slide of the Soviet Union into oblivion.
In the modern history of warfare, the Cold War seems to be the only one where victory is in dispute. And it is liberal academic opinion that has created the fiction that nobody won. There is no more Soviet Union, no Berlin Wall, no gulag. Never mind. The United States did not "win" the Cold War, and that's that.
Now that's really weird. Ask who won World War I, World War II or the war in Vietnam, the answers are readily forthcoming: The Allies beat Kaiser Wilhelm, then they beat Adolf Hitler, the United States lost to North Vietnam. Ask who won the war over the Falkland Islands, the answer is undisputed: Britain. But when it comes to the question of who triumphed in the Cold War, a great smog immediately blankets the question. The response by George Kennan, is simple. "Nobody," he now writes, " `won' the Cold War." And any suggestion that President Reagan had anything to do with winning the Cold War, Mr. Kennan writes, "is intrinsically silly and childish."
Professor Ronald Steel has written this grudging verdict on freedom's bloodless victory over Soviet totalitarianism: "We have won a victory, of sorts." Of sorts. Would Mr. Steel describe our triumph over fascism as "a victory, of sorts"? Because we won the Cold War, we are the only superpower, he writes, "yet this is an ambiguous victory." What's ambiguous about it? The one-time "evil empire," as Mr. Reagan called it to jeers from the liberal left, is no more; the Soviet Union is a collection of some 15 nation states; Germany is united; Central Europe is free of Soviet domination; democracy flourishes where once dictators reigned. What's "ambiguous"?
Mr. Steel, like others of his liberal persuasion, seems to regret the end of the Cold War; he writes: "In its perverted way, the Cold War was a force for stability." Yes indeed -bloodily suppressed uprisings in East Germany and Hungary, Poland, Czechoslovakia, trampling of human rights, Afghanistan, Soviet support …