A government-appointed council of senior religious scholars in Saudi Arabia condemned terrorism financing and said it is forbidden by Islamic law.
Saudi Arabia's top religious leaders have condemned terrorism financing as forbidden by Islamic law, giving added religious weight and potentially larger punishments to existing civil statutes.
But many analysts are skeptical it will amount to much. The government-appointed Council of Senior Ulema, which issued the resolution, holds little weight with those inclined to support militants. Some Saudi Arabians view their government as too eager to please the US in its quest to stop terrorism and question the religious and moral legitimacy of the monarchy. "Ulema" is an Arabic word the roughly translates as "Muslim scholar."
And Saudi officials agree that for some militants or their supporters, this stand against terrorist funding won't resonate.
"The extremists, for them it wouldn't make a difference, because they have their own little fatwa mills where they issue fatwas left and right," says Nail Al-Jubeir, spokesman for the Saudi embassy in Washington. "They're going to issue their own fatwas saying it's the duty of every person to help them, but it doesn't go anywhere. They're just talking to their own group of people."
Still, Mr. Jubeir says the government hopes the ruling will eliminate any misunderstandings about what constitutes support for militant groups and deter people from sending financial support to such organizations.
Among some analysts, there's a view that the resolution was created to show the West that Saudi Arabia is committed to fighting terrorism, rather than to be an effective counterterrorism measure in itself.
"This is a political display of opposition to terrorist activities," says Hilal Khashan, a professor of political science at the American University of Beirut. "The main threat does not come from officially sanctioned contributions to groups that are regarded as militant and anti-Western. The main threat comes from private donations made by Saudi business people and wealthy individuals and the Saudi statement does not control private donations."
Government-linked charities used to fund a number of groups accused of terrorism, but under US pressure Saudi Arabia changed its practices about six years ago and liquidated the Al-Haramain Foundation, a particular target of US ire.
The council's resolution drew from the Koran, Sunnah (traditions of the Prophet Mohammed's life), and Islamic law. The council ruled that "the financing of terrorism; the inception, help or attempt to commit a terrorist act whatever kind or dimension is forbidden by Islamic Shariah and constitutes a punishable crime thereby. …