From Mr Peter Goldsmith, QC
Sir: Polly Toynbee's "new order" for the court system (18 May) would pose a fundamental threat to the very rights and freedoms that any newspaper which flatters itself with the virtue of independence should seek to defend.
Her article confuses the earnings that senior barristers are reported to make from their work in private practice, principally commercial work, with the rates paid under legal aid. Most of the rates quoted in the article have nothing to do with legal aid.
The facts are these: lawyers' fees in criminal legal aid cases are controlled both by the Government and, where necessary, judicial officers. Barristers do not set out their own fees for legal-aid Crown Court work. They are paid what the Government allows under comprehensive regulations setting out the fees to be paid. The regulations set standard rates, which cover the majority of Crown Court work. For example, the standard fee for all the preparation for, and attendance at, a one-day hearing is pounds 257. In other cases, the fees to be paid are determined by government officials.
Fee claims under pounds 4,000 are vetted by determining officers in the court. These are government officials who work for the Lord Chancellor's Department, which has overall responsibility for the legal aid budget. Fee claims over pounds 4,000 are vetted by regional taxing teams of more experienced determining officers - still government officials - and they can have two bites at reducing lawyers' fees. In both cases, the lawyer can appeal to the taxing masters who have judicial status. …