EDITOR'S NOTE
This article first appeared as a Walker Information white paper. It is reprinted here to increase its availability in the hope of stimulating continuing dialogue on this topic. It is reprinted by permission of Walker Information who copyrighted it in 2001.
In the interest of academic fairness, full discussions from each party represented in this "debate" are available in white paper form on their respective web sites. Grisaffe's paper can be accessed at www.walkerinfo.com/resources, then click on "white papers", then click on "Loyalty-- Attitude, Behavior, and Good Science...." Brandt's paper can be accessed at www.burke.com, then click on "search" and type …