Academic journal article
By McNish, Ian
Mankind Quarterly , Vol. 45, No. 4
The Myth of Syphilis: The Natural History of Treponematosis in North America Editors: Mary Lucas Powell and Delia Collins Cook University Press of Florida, 2005
Exploring the long-standing question of the origins of syphilis, this hook proposes a new understanding of the dynamic interactions of disease and culture in the New World. It brings together a complete picture of the diverse pathological evidence of a bacterial disease - treponematosis - manifest in the North American archaeological record at the time of Christopher Columbus's first journey, and it presents a strong argument against the earlier identification of modern venereal syphilis with indigenous North American treponemal disease.
For almost 500 years, native North Americans have been blamed for "giving the world syphilis" and by implication have been accused of sexual immorality. Contributors to this volume identify and investigate the origins and various manifestations of all ranges of treponemal diseases across the continent and show that the true picture of disease evolution is both different and far more interesting than past scholarship suggests. They summarize current archaeological and historical information from a variety of regions and times, both before and after 1492, and consider closely the specific question of whether evidence exists for the presence of the venereal form of treponemal disease that would be equivalent to the venereal syphilis that ravaged 16th-century Europe. Their investigation challenges the unequivocal identification of all pre-Columbian treponemal disease as venereal syphilis and shows that endemic treponemal disease was present at varying levels throughout North America for at least two millennia before the late 15th-century transAtlantic voyages of discovery.
Mary Lucas Powell, a former director of the W. S. Webb Museum of Anthropology at the University of Kentucky, and Delia Collins Cook, professor of anthropology at Indiana University, have edited this collection of papers contributed by over thirty specialists. While it will primarily be of interest to those concerned with paleopathology, and deals mostly with the Americas, it nevertheless provides an interesting historical account of what we know about the regional origins and historical spread of not only the North American variety of this disease, but the four other main varieties. …