U.S. Election History

election

election, choosing a candidate for office in an organization by the vote of those enfranchised to cast a ballot.

General History

In ancient Greek democracies (e.g., Athens) public officials were occasionally elected but more often were chosen by lot. In Rome the popular assemblies elected the tribunes. In the Middle Ages elections were abandoned, except for such processes as elections to the papacy and, in a more limited sense, of the Holy Roman emperor by a small and partly hereditary body of electors.

In the modern period, elections have been inseparable from the growth of democratic forms of government. Elections were associated with the parliamentary process in England from the 13th cent. and were gradually regularized by acts prescribing the frequency of elections (the Triennial Act of 1694, and the Septennial Act of 1716), by successive reform bills widening the franchise in the 19th cent., and by the adoption of the secret ballot in 1872.

Elections in the United States

In colonial America the election of church and public officials dates almost from the founding of the Plymouth Colony, and the paper ballot was instituted in elections to the Massachusetts governorship in 1634. Under the U.S. Constitution the right to hold elections is specified, but the method and place are left to the states, with Congress having the power to alter their regulations. The Constitution specified that elections to the House of Representatives be direct, or popular, and that the election of the Senate and of the president and vice president be indirect, Senators being chosen by the state legislatures and the president and vice president by electors selected by the people (see electoral college). The Seventeenth Amendment (1913) provided for popular election of senators.

Political candidates are usually chosen by delegate convention, direct primary, nonpartisan primaries, or petition. The candidate who receives the most votes is usually elected, but an absolute majority may be required; a majority has not been required in the U.S. federal elections since 1850 except in the electoral vote cast for the president and vice president. (In presidential nominating conventions an absolute majority is required; the Democrats required a two-thirds vote of the delegates from 1832 to 1936.)

Since 1824, when John Quincy Adams was elected president by the House of Representatives when no candidate had a majority in the electoral college (Adams' leading opponent, Andrew Jackson, had greater popular and electoral vote totals), the electoral-college system has many times permitted a president to be chosen without a majority of the popular vote (1844, 1848, 1856, 1860, 1876, 1880, 1884, 1888, 1892, 1912, 1916, 1948, 1960, 1968, 1992, 1996, and 2000); in 1876, 1888, and 2000 candidates without even a plurality succeeded in winning office.

Voting frauds and disorder at the polls were common after the rise of political machines, and the enactment of registration laws after 1865 did little to ameliorate conditions. Corrupt practices acts, poll watching, the institution of primary elections, and the introduction of voting machines after 1892 have been more effective in ensuring honest elections. Nonetheless, the disputes over the counting of the votes in Florida in the 2000 presidential election clearly revealed that some machine voting systems are more reliable than others and that less reliable systems can potentially distort the results.

All states have some residency requirements as a condition for suffrage. Originally the vote was typically restricted to white men who met certain property qualifications; such restrictions were later liberalized and removed. The Fourteenth Amendment (1868) and Fifteenth Amendment (1870) were designed to forbid the disenfranchisement of African-American men after the Civil War, and the Nineteenth (1920) conferred the vote on women. The Twenty-third Amendment (1961) permitted residents of the District of Columbia to vote in the presidential elections, while the Twenty-fourth Amendment (1964) outlawed payment of poll or other taxes as a condition for voting. The Twenty-sixth Amendment (1971) lowered the voting age from 21 to 18. The so-called motor voter law (National Voter Registration Act, 1993) was designed to reverse declining voter registrations by permitting registration at motor vehicle departments and other agencies. Certain classes of felons and some others are deprived of the vote.

Types of Representation

In the United States, Canada, Mexico, Great Britain, and many other nations, usually the one candidate who receives the most votes is elected from a district. If an absolute majority is needed to win, a run-off election maybe required. In Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Russia, Ukraine, Brazil, and other nations (including some local elections in the United States), proportional representation is used to more adequately represent political or other minorities within the electorate. Two methods are used—the voter ranking system in a multiseat district, and the party list system in which parties gaining a threshold vote win one seat and those well above the threshold dividing the remaining seats proportionally. While a proportional system provides representation for minorities and eliminates gerrymandering, primaries, and run-off elections, it can weaken the representative-constituent relationship, encourage multiple parties, and necessitate coalition rather than majority governments. Some nations, for example, Italy, Germany, and Spain, use a combination of direct election and proportional representation.

Bibliography

See E. Lakeman, How Democracies Vote (1970); E. H. Rosebloom, A History of Presidential Elections (3d ed. 1970); H. A. Bone, American Politics and the Party System (4th ed. 1971) and Politics and Voters (3d ed. 1971); J. M. Clubb, ed., Electoral Change and Stability in American Political History (1971); J. H. Silbey et al., The History of American Electoral Behavior (1978); S. A. and B. G. Samore, Candidates, Parties, and Campaigns (1985); W. R. Neuman, The Paradox of Mass Politics (1986).

The Columbia Encyclopedia, 6th ed. Copyright© 2014, The Columbia University Press.

Selected full-text books and articles on this topic

You Call This An Election? America's Peculiar Democracy
Steven E. Schier.
Georgetown University Press, 2003
The Politics of Disappointment: American Elections, 1976-94
Wilson Carey McWilliams.
Chatham House Publishers, 1995
Beyond the Politics of Disappointment? American Elections, 1980-1998
Wilson Carey McWilliams.
Chatham House Publishers, 2000
Presidential Elections in the United States: A Statistical History, 1860-1992
Russell O. Wright.
McFarland, 1995
Campaigning in America: A History of Election Practices
Robert J. Dinkin.
Greenwood Press, 1989
The Pursuit of the White House: A Handbook of Presidential Election Statistics and History
G. Scott Thomas.
Greenwood Press, 1987
The Obama Victory: How Media, Money, and Message Shaped the 2008 Election
Kate Kenski; Bruce W. Hardy; Kathleen Hall Jamieson.
Oxford University Press, 2010
Breaking the Deadlock: The 2000 Election, the Constitution, and the Courts
Richard A. Posner.
Princeton University Press, 2001
The Election of 2000: Reports and Interpretations
Gerald M. Pomper; Anthony Corrado; E. J. Dionne Jr.; Kathleen A. Frankovic; Paul S. Herrnson; Marjorie Randon Hershey; William G. Mayer; Monika L. McDermott; Wilson Carey McWilliams.
Chatham House Publishers, 2001
The Election of 1996: Reports and Interpretations
Gerald M. Pomper; Walter Dean Burnham; Anthony Corrado; Marjorie Randon Hershey; Marion R. Just; Scott Keeter; Wilson Carey McWilliams; William G. Mayer.
Chatham House, 1997
The Election of 1980: Reports and Interpretations
Gerald M. Pomper; Marlene Michels Pomper.
Chatham House Publishers, 1981
The Making of a Catholic President: Kennedy vs. Nixon 1960
Shaun A. Casey.
Oxford University Press, 2009
The Presidential Election of 1880
Herbert J. S. J. Clancy.
Loyola University Press, 1958
The Birth of Modern Politics: Andrew Jackson, John Quincy Adams, and the Election of 1828
Lynn Hudson Parsons.
Oxford University Press, 2009
Adams vs. Jefferson: The Tumultuous Election of 1800
John Ferling.
Oxford University Press, 2004
Search for more books and articles on U.S. election history