By Spalding, John D.
The Christian Century , Vol. 120, No. 11
Conduct of Life--Ethical Aspects
Conduct of Life--Political Aspects
Politicians--Beliefs, Opinions and Attitudes
Bennett, William J.--Political aspects
Bennett, William J.--Ethical aspects
Bennett, William J.--Beliefs, opinions and attitudes
SHOULD WE judge Bill Bennett for being an obsessive gambler, for losing over $1 million in a two-month period and $8 million over ten years? He wouldn't have it any other way. In his 1998 bestseller, The Death of Outrage, Bennett bemoaned the wretched moral state of our nation, and said part of the problem is that we're afraid to judge people on moral issues. "We live in an era when it has become unfashionable to make judgments on a whole range of consequential behaviors and attitudes." He called for a revival of judgmentalism. "If to make judgments of better and worse, good and bad, fit and unfit, sound and unsound, competent and incompetent is to be judgmental," he wrote, "then there is a need to be judgmental and no need to apologize for it.... For a free people, the ordeal of judgment cannot be shirked. To try to shirk it is to avoid responsibility."
Bennett has never shirked that responsibility himself. He has climbed into positions of high moral authority--as director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy and before that secretary of education--and has spent decades tirelessly crusading against moral lapses. He believes public figures must be held to tough standards, for they are all role models, "When it comes to embracing and exemplifying core ethical values," he writes, "we must all do our part." Just think of the kids: "Children watch what we do as well as what say, and if we expect them to take morality seriously, they must see adults taking it seriously."
We recall how Bennett assailed Bill Clinton for his "sexual indiscipline," which he found "alarming in its compulsiveness, self-indulgence, and carelessness. …