Why the Death Penalty Is
Louis P. Pojman
The death penalty as punishment for the most serious crimes is morally justified. Honest people and philosophers may disagree on these matters, but I will present my reasons for supporting the retention of this practice. I have no illusions about my ability to change the minds of my ardent abolitionist opponents, but I can hope to clear the air of misperceptions and help those with an open mind come to an informed judgment of this crucial matter.
First, let me briefly comment on specific claims in Hugo Bedau's essay “An Abolitionist's Survey of the Death Penalty in America Today.” 1 (1) Bedau contends that “today it ought to be impossible not to regard death in the electric chair as ‘cruel and unusual punishment’ in direct violation of such punishments in the Eighth Amendment in____________________