Technology and the Unity of
Humans strive to realize limitless potential. Unfortunately, at various stages of the development of civilization, higher achievement for some has been bought at the cost of the degradation of others. Being associated with technology was not always highly regarded. In fact, people involved with the practical arts and vocations of technology have been viewed, in the past, as inferior.
In Western civilization, ancient Athens is noted for the contempt of its philosophers for those whose pursuits were other than ethereal. Aristotle would have denied them the rights of citizenship (Aristotle 1958, 107–9). Plato would have denied citizenship to peasants, artisans, and mechanics and would not have wanted his daughter to marry one of their sons (Plato 1960, 234–35; Plato 1952, 89). The attitude toward those who worked furnaces that made the metals for Iron Age Greece was one of even greater scorn. Xenophon said those who tended the fires carried “a social stigma” and were “rightly dishonored” in the Greek cities (Farrington 1944, 28).
There were two reasons the Greek philosophers felt the way they did. Mechanical arts were unpleasant to perform and debilitating to those who carried them out. Working with fire meant “blood, toil, tears, and sweat” (Farrington 1944, 26). Given their unpleasantness, such tasks were carried out by slaves. The stigma of this association carried over to free men engaged in manual technological endeavors. No wonder that, in Greece and elsewhere, higher pursuits were preferred by those who were able to follow them.
In India at the turn of the twentieth century, scholars blamed “the estrangement of the hand from the mind for the decline of science”(Ghosh 1994, 6; Ray 1902–3, 1909). Alsop (1982) says that in the early centuries of Chinese civilization, “any work of art smelling too much of technical training, including technically skillful painting, tended to be looked down by many Chinese art theorists as being too close to artisans' work. On the other hand, a proper
Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Publication information: Book title: Bountiful Harvest:Technology, Food Safety, and the Environment. Contributors: Thomas R. Degregori - Author. Publisher: Cato Institute. Place of publication: Washington, DC. Publication year: 2002. Page number: 1.
This material is protected by copyright and, with the exception of fair use, may not be further copied, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means.