While the dating of this unpublished fragment remains uncertain, it accurately reflects Lincoln's views about the war and slavery after he issued the Emancipation Proclamation. Critics often asked the president what he would do if the South stopped fighting and desired to return to the Union. Let them try me, he once retorted. In this piece, Lincoln hinted that he could not continue the war if the other side wanted peace. The question meant little in practical terms, and Lincoln used it as a rhetorical opportunity to affirm his administration's unwavering commitment to the Union. He also made clear here and elsewhere that if peace came, he would not return anyone to slavery, especially those who had been enrolled into the army. However, he also admitted that if a court properly ordered such an action, he would be obligated to obey it. Given the right circumstances, as in a border state like Kentucky, Lincoln confessed that he might not be able to live up to his pledge that he would never return to slavery someone freed by acts of Congress or the Emancipation Proclamation.
[August 26, 1863?]
Suppose those now in rebellion should say: “We cease
fighting: re-establish the national authority amongst
us—customs, courts, mails, land-offices,—all as before
the rebellion—we claiming to send members to both
branches of Congress, as of yore, and to hold our slaves
according to our State laws, notwithstanding anything
or all things which has occurred during the rebellion.” I
probably should answer: “It will be difficult to justify in
reason, or to maintain in fact, a war on one side, which
shall have ceased on the other. You began the war, and
Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Publication information: Book title: Lincoln on Race and Slavery. Contributors: Henry Louis Gates Jr. - Editor, Donald Yacovone - Editor, Abraham Lincoln - Author. Publisher: Princeton University Press. Place of publication: Princeton, NJ. Publication year: 2009. Page number: 290.
This material is protected by copyright and, with the exception of fair use, may not be further copied, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means.