EXPERIENCE AND REVELATION
WHY do we believe God exists? This is an extraordinarily difficult question to answer, for several reasons. In the first place, it depends very much upon us. It may quite well be the case that no two people have come to believe in God in precisely the same way, and that no two people would give exactly the same set of reasons to justify their belief. But this does not mean that their reasons are necessarily unsound, for there may be quite a number of different arguments leading to a particular conclusion and all of them may be perfectly valid. If, however, we try to set up a body of argument which we feel would convince a perfectly reasonable man, we shall probably lay ourselves open to the charge of artificiality. For the perfectly Reasonable Man is as much an abstraction as is the Economic Man or the Average Man, as Mr. A. P. Herbert has amusingly demonstrated in one of his "Misleading Cases." "Devoid, in short, of any human weakness, with not one saving vice, sans prejudice, procrastination, ill-nature, avarice, and absence of mind, as careful for his own safety as he is for that of others, this excellent but odious character," said Mr. Justice Marrow, "stands like a monument in our Courts of Justice, vainly appealing to his fellow-citizens to order their lives after his own example. . . . All solid virtues are his, save only that peculiar quality by which the affection of other men is won." And, in fact, he is a myth.
As a matter of experience, most Christians have acquired their belief in the existence of God in extremely elaborate ways, which have varied widely from case to case, and which it is most difficult to disentangle into their component parts in such a way as to display a logical and coherent argument. This is not, however, as discreditable to Christian belief as it might seem. For the same thing is true about almost all the beliefs by which our lives from day to day are governed. Very few married men, for example, could give a perfectly watertight answer to the question, "How do you know that your wife really loves you?" Presumably, in most instances, if he was really forced to it, a man could put up some sort of case for the fidelity of the lady in question, but it is very
Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Publication information: Book title: He Who Is:A Study in Traditional Theism. Contributors: E. L. B. D. Mascall - Author. Publisher: Longmans, Green. Place of publication: London. Publication year: 1943. Page number: 14.
This material is protected by copyright and, with the exception of fair use, may not be further copied, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means.