Global Integration in the Banking Industry
Berger, Allen N., Smith, David C., Judge, Jennifer, Federal Reserve Bulletin
Many observers believe that significant global integration is under way in the banking industry and that, in the coming years, individual banks will expand their reach into many countries. Likewise, these observers expect that many national banking markets will develop large foreign components; as that happens, the nationality of a bank in such a market will matter little to prospective customers. (1)
These forecasts are based on the observation that, over the past two or three decades, many nations have removed important regulatory barriers to international banking. Advances in technology also now allow financial institutions to manage larger information flows across more locations and to evaluate and manage risks at lower costs than ever before. Together, these developments have reduced the costs of supplying banking services across borders. At the same time, growth in the international activities and trade of multinational corporations has increased the demand for services from financial institutions that operate across borders.
Despite these developments, the banking industry appears today to be far from globally integrated, particularly in industrialized countries. For example, the foreign share of bank assets in most industrialized countries remains at or below 10 percent. And although bank consolidation has been intense within industrialized countries, mergers and acquisitions across the borders of these countries have been much less common. (2)
To evaluate more closely the extent to which banking is becoming globally integrated, we study the nationality and international reach of banks that provide financial services across Europe to affiliates of multinational corporations. We examine these affiliates because they are among the customers most likely to demand the services of international banks, and we focus on Europe because barriers to financial integration have been extensively reduced on that continent. A finding that banking integration has advanced little even under such favorable conditions would cast doubt on the prospects for the globalization of banking more generally.
We rely mostly on an extensive, carefully conducted 1996 survey of the short-term banking practices of more than 2,000 European affiliates of multinational corporations. Perhaps surprisingly, we find that close to two-thirds of these affiliates choose a bank headquartered in the nation in which they are operating (a host-nation bank) rather than a bank from their home country or a third nation. Moreover, having chosen a host-nation bank, an affiliate is more likely to select a bank limited to local or regional operations rather than a large bank with global reach.
We also examine time-series data that might reveal the degree to which global integration has increased over the past decade. These data cover European syndicated loans, the ratio of domestic private bank claims to total (domestic plus foreign) bank claims, and the dispersion of nonfinancial goods prices across Europe. In brief, the time-series data show a picture for the current period that is not substantially different from that at the time of the 1996 survey.
These results are consistent with the idea that affiliates value host-nation banks over others because host-nation banks better understand their own market and may possess superior information about local nonfinancial suppliers and customers. Our results also imply that affiliates that have chosen host-nation banks value the more customized and relationship-based services offered by banks with local or regional reach, as opposed to the broad-based services offered by a host-nation bank that has global reach.
Our findings suggest that even as economic forces push toward globalization, the high demand for host-based expertise by bank customers, coupled with the competitive advantages that host-nation banks have in providing this expertise, implies that …
Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Publication information: Article title: Global Integration in the Banking Industry. Contributors: Berger, Allen N. - Author, Smith, David C. - Author, Judge, Jennifer - Author. Journal title: Federal Reserve Bulletin. Volume: 89. Issue: 11 Publication date: November 2003. Page number: 451+. © 1999 Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. COPYRIGHT 2003 Gale Group.
This material is protected by copyright and, with the exception of fair use, may not be further copied, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means.