More Than Gatekeepers: High School Guidance Counselors Have Extraordinary Influence in Steering Black Males to College or to the Streets
Cook, Omar M., Bush, Lawson, V, Bush, Edward C., Diverse Issues in Higher Education
Black males have chronically been in the lower percentiles of students qualifying for entry to four-year institutions as compared to other ethnic and gender groups. There are a myriad of axiomatic factors such as a lack of opportunities to learn because of less qualified instructors and advanced course offerings, institutional racism, and incongruent cultural backgrounds that have contributed to this quandary. Yet, the role guidance counselors play in this matter has been significantly understudied and severely underestimated.
In Omar Cook's (2007) dissertation, "African-American Males' Reflections on Their Preparation and Access to Post-Secondary Opportunities: The Impact of Counselors' Activities, Interactions and Roles in Urban Schools," he found that counselors may be more than passive gatekeepers as suggested by previous scholars, playing a more assertive role in funneling Black males away from college altogether or into the California community colleges. Moreover, the study suggests that non-Black counselors showed an unwillingness to consistently provide unequivocal, adequate and sufficient college-related pedagogical practices, options, pathways, and services to African-American males. This is evidenced in the following quotes by two participants of the study:
"Her race (Caucasian) was a factor. None of the counselors put much priority behind Black students. I think it was just an assumption that we were not interested in education beyond high school."
"Her race (Caucasian) was a factor. I think she had a little bit of bias and favoritism with White kids. She communicated more with them by asking more questions and going in-depth with options and benefits regarding college stuff. We only had "in and out" sessions that were very limited in communication regarding college and personal inquiries."
These types of interactions can directly influence college-going rates. In looking at college attendance data as of fall 2006, 81 percent of all Black males in California public colleges and universities were enrolled in California community colleges in comparison to 70 percent of White males and 60 percent of Asian males. In addition, Black males attend community colleges in greater numbers than Black females, according to the California Postsecondary Education Commission 2006 report. As of fall 2006, there was a total of 58,486 Black males enrolled in California public institutions of higher education. Among the percent of Black males enrolled in California public colleges in fall 2006, 4 percent attended a school in the University of California system, 15 percent attended a California State University and 81 percent were at community colleges.
The relegation of Black males …
Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Publication information: Article title: More Than Gatekeepers: High School Guidance Counselors Have Extraordinary Influence in Steering Black Males to College or to the Streets. Contributors: Cook, Omar M. - Author, Bush, Lawson, V - Author, Bush, Edward C. - Author. Magazine title: Diverse Issues in Higher Education. Volume: 25. Issue: 13 Publication date: August 7, 2008. Page number: 19. © 2008 Cox, Matthews & Associates. COPYRIGHT 2008 Gale Group.