The Modern World through the Luminous Path of Prose Fiction: Reading Graham Greene's A Burnt-Out Case and the Confidential Agent as Dystopian Novels
Kehinde, Ayobami, Nebula
What an absurd thing it was to expect happiness in a world so full of misery.... Point me out the happy man and I will point you out either egotisms, evil--or else an absolute ignorance (Graham Greene, The Heart of the Matter, 1948: 117)
Graham Greene was undoubtedly one of the most gifted and acclaimed novelists of the War/Post-war era in Britain. His novels reflect a constant search for new novelistic modes of expression capable of visualizing the disillusionment and malaise of the modern world. According to Waldo Clarke (1976), an enduring trait of Greene's fiction is the willingness to look at the repulsive face of the twentieth century. Since literature mostly reflects the mood of its age and enabling contexts, Greene's fiction dwells on the conflicts and pains of the modern world. The central burden of this discourse is to prove that Greene's novels steadily progressed in his bold use of the convention of dystopian fiction. It has been proved elsewhere that Greene's The Power and the Glory and The Heart of the Matter are quintessential existential dystopian novels (See: Ayo Kehinde, 2004). However, in this present paper, an attempt is made to study more closely the dystopian features and political and ideological implications of the deployment of this convention in Greene's The Confidential Agent and A Burnt-out Case. But first we must look closely at the concept of dystopian fiction and its role in fictional discourse.
Western imaginative literature took a decidedly dystopian turn in the twentieth century; this was with a view to reflecting the problems of the Western world in that century of wars and agonies. In fact, actual experiences of the modern world have been dystopian. This called for strong dystopian features in the literary texts produced in that period. According to Keith Booker (1995), "in many ways, dystopian fiction has become a paradigmatic expression of the Western imagination in the twentieth century" (58).
Dystopian fiction is a generic term for a work that is skeptical about ideal states and is fearful of totalitarian thought control. In such fictional work, the future is depicted as a nightmare world of state or corporate control and of dehumanized mechanization (Edward Quinn, 2006). In dystopian fiction, the novelist is always blunt; he or she uses the text to interrogate the idyllic posture of the pre-twentieth century utopianism. This is due to certain sad and unexpected events in the contemporary world--cold and violent wars; revolutions; totalitarianism, like Hitler's Germany and Stalin's Russia, and the like. In such a bleak world, the powerful are capable of destroying themselves and all of mankind; governments can also bend people to any kind of purpose. Barbara Foley (1993) sums up the features of the cosmos of a dystopian work in the following words: "oppositional confrontation between the desires of a presumably unique individual and demands of an oppressive society that insists on total obedience and conformity in its subjects" (21). Thus, the world of dystopian fiction offers a stifling threat to the freedom and integrity of the individual.
It is against the backdrop of the foregoing that the world of Greene's novels should be considered. Like most of Greene's novels, The Confidential Agent and A Burnout Case raise questions about the modern world, its predicaments and destination. Predictably, the image of humanity that the novels offer is negative. Nothing can better testify to Greene's talent than his artistic holding up of a fictional mirror to the existential pangs of the modern world; that is, his ingenious depiction of life under siege, a world bereft of fulfillment and joy. In fact, Greene's treatment of the dissonant and painful realities of humanity in the modern world is both remarkable and unique. His fiction shows a shift in the belief in Robert Browning's comforting refrain: "God's in his Heaven/All's right with the world!" (From: "Pippa's Passes", 1841). The characters are out of step with their societies because the values of the societies are seen as warped or misguided. Those characters might be considered evil or psychoanalytically troubled, but they should also be seen as products of their societies, as personalities shaped by the problems of those societies and by the warped values the societies have come to represent. The characters rebel against the pressure and stress of the modern world, but, according to a seemingly ineluctable strategy of containment, they pay for their temporary emancipation with some significant loss of lives and of social respectability.
The Confidential Agent is classified by Greene himself as an "Entertainment". However, a close reading of it reveals that it is a serious and highly accomplished work of art that dwells on some issues which border on the existential problems of man in the modern world. Although the "entertainment" essence is there (actually, it is a good story that gives pleasure), it still possesses the quality which any good novel must have--topicality, in terms of serious issues, neat plot and structure, ability to create suspense, and abiding didactic overtones. Thus, although the novel can pass for an adventure tale, it is yet a subtle and double-edged criticism of the social ills and malaise of the modern world. As a dystopian novel, there is a background story of war, revolution, uprising, natural disaster and some other painful events which result in dramatic changes to the societies.
Set in England, during a civil war in a neighbouring country (Holland), The Confidential Agent traces the gradual dehumanization and brutalization of a spy (D). It shows how a person can degenerate into crime and violence in such a situation. In line with a tenet of dystopian fiction, D is a protagonist who questions his society, because he often feels intuitively that something is terribly wrong with it. In the novel, Greene presents the problems of humanity in the modern world by a most skilful manipulation of plot and structure, depicting each stage of brutalization and frustration processes, proceeding very logically and inevitably from the preceding. D goes to England hopefully to get the coal which he is bound to miss getting. We witness a rather static world, where to struggle is to grope towards doom and failure. The search of D and L (two rival confidential agents) for coal is doomed to failure because of Greene's vision of an end to the pervading crises plaguing the world. Since neither D nor L could get the consignment of coal, it is pertinent for both warring groups to cease fire. He also proffers a linguistic solution to the problem of global crises. Dr. Bellows' project on 'Entrenationo', a hybrid language, aims at giving a linguistic solution to world tension.
The reader's first impression of D is of innocence. Greene does not fail to capture the initial thrill of the moment--the garrulity and exuberance of Rose do not go unnoticed. However, Greene still carefully suggests that behind the facade of the thrill and innocence, there are sinister omens waiting to blight the nearest future. The reader is introduced to quite a lot of ravaging dystopian images, including gulls, mourning, death, half-speed, fog, coffin and heat. War, a ubiquitous fact of the modern world, is a common motif in dystopian fiction. A civil war is going on in D's country (Holland); another one is going on half a mile outside Dover Breakwater. D is obsessed with war: "He carried the war with him; wherever D was, there was a war" (9). A dystopian society glorifies and justifies violence, therefore bringing upon itself violence. Hence, …
Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Publication information: Article title: The Modern World through the Luminous Path of Prose Fiction: Reading Graham Greene's A Burnt-Out Case and the Confidential Agent as Dystopian Novels. Contributors: Kehinde, Ayobami - Author. Journal title: Nebula. Volume: 6. Issue: 2 Publication date: June 2009. Page number: 82+. © 2009 NobleWorld. COPYRIGHT 2009 Gale Group.
This material is protected by copyright and, with the exception of fair use, may not be further copied, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means.