Annual Intellectual Property Law Review Banquet Speech: Lessons Learned from Fifteen Years in the Trenches of Patent Litigation

McDermott, Rick, Marquette Intellectual Property Law Review

I would like to thank Professor Irene Calboli, Professor Michael O'Hear, and the staff of the Marquette Intellectual Property Law Review for inviting me to speak at this year's banquet. When Professor Calboli first extended the invitation, I gladly accepted, thinking what a great opportunity to speak to a group of people--primarily students interested in intellectual property law--about a substantive IP law topic. Then, I started thinking about the possible IP law topics that a group of law students might want to listen to on a Friday night. While I have been out of law school over fifteen years, which was not that long ago, I soon realized that the universe of possible topics was quickly dwindling.

If nothing else, perhaps my fifteen years practicing in the IP field, primarily focused on patent infringement litigation, can impart one or two lessons, and a few good stories, all of which I thought you might enjoy tonight, and which might also enlighten your path as many of you proceed with your own legal practice, in the IP field or otherwise. In that regard, I thought I would comment on a few things that have impacted the nature of my practice over the past fifteen years, including several court decisions as well as the economics of IP, and the economy itself. While I am sure that the word "economy" has become a four letter word to many of you, stick with me on this one--its impact on IP might not be as obvious or perhaps as negative as you might think.

Just over fifteen years ago, and fresh out of law school, I started practicing law in Charlotte, North Carolina, at Bell Seltzer Park & Gibson, a mid-sized IP boutique with just two offices--both in North Carolina. Being the high-tech, electrical IP lawyer that I was, it was only appropriate that the first case I was assigned concerned patents relating to the ultra-pasteurization of egg product. That is right, egg product--egg product that is pasteurized at a sufficiently high temperature so as to impart a shelf life of up to about thirty-five weeks so that your favorite restaurant or fast food joint can safely keep sufficient quantities of the egg product around to serve you and their other customers without fear of salmonella or other harmful bacteria. While the technology was not quite "up my alley," I learned a lot working on that case. We dealt with claim construction issues, infringement issues, invalidity issues, damages issues, reexamination proceedings, reissue proceedings, trial preparation, and more. And by the way, we did most of that without the use of e-mail, the Internet, electronic filing, etc.

I learned one of my first, and perhaps most valuable lessons working on that case--that knowledge and experience comes in all shapes and sizes, and to fully appreciate and take advantage of that knowledge and experience, you have to be open to the various shapes and sizes. While it seemed at first like my four undergraduate years learning about circuits, transistors, capacitors, and the like were going to be wasted as I started swimming in egg product, the experience was invaluable and a great way to kick-off my career as a patent lawyer.

Within a year or so after I started working, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued its en banc decision in Markman v. Westview Instruments, (1) which upheld the decision of a district court judge, which overturned a jury verdict based on the jury's improper claim construction. By upholding that decision, the court determined that claim construction is a matter of law, thereby assigning to the judge, not the jury, the sole responsibility for construing or interpreting the meaning of patent claims. While there was a strong dissent within the en banc panel at the Federal Circuit, the Supreme Court unanimously affirmed the decision of the Federal Circuit, indicating that the "decisionmaker vested with the task of …

Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Publication information: Article title: Annual Intellectual Property Law Review Banquet Speech: Lessons Learned from Fifteen Years in the Trenches of Patent Litigation. Contributors: McDermott, Rick - Author. Journal title: Marquette Intellectual Property Law Review. Volume: 14. Issue: 2 Publication date: Summer 2010. Page number: 471+. © 2007 Marquette University Law School. COPYRIGHT 2010 Gale Group.

This material is protected by copyright and, with the exception of fair use, may not be further copied, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means.