Language Games of International Law: Koskenniemi as the Discipline's Wittgenstein
Carty, Anthony, Melbourne Journal of International Law
THE POLITICS OF INTERNATIONAL LAW BY MARTTI KOSKENNIEMI (HART PUBLISHING, OXFORD, UK AND PORTLAND, OREGON, 2011) 371 PAGES. PRICE US$70.00 (PAPERBACK) ISBN 9781841139395.
CONTENTS I Introduction II The Non-Philosophy and the Non-Theory of the Politics of International Law III The High Priest and the Perpetual Confession of Liberal International Law IV A Mirror into the Soul of the International Lawyer V The Anguish of the Soul of the International Lawyer in the Face of Nuclear Dilemmas VI History of International Lawyers' Vocabularies as Philosophy of International Law
This volume provides another, almost accidental, opportunity to reflect on the work of Martti Koskenniemi after the review which the author wrote in the Michigan Journal of International Law in 1990. (1) That review argued that the shadow of natural law was a ghost haunting the critical approach to international law which Koskenniemi represents. It received no critical response from Koskenniemi. It received a brief mention in the Epilogue to the second edition of From Apology to Utopia. (2) Emmanuelle Jouannet, in her critical introduction, informs the reader that Koskenniemi has never intended to produce a 'theory of international law ('3) and 'indeed he would object to the very term itself, as his goal has never been to be perceived as a legal theoretician or philosopher but rather as an international lawyer addressing other international lawyers'. (4) His aim is not
the production of a general theory of law, but rather the clarification of practice and discourse of international lawyers--or perhaps more accurately, the discourses and the practices that appear to him simply as different styles that we can adopt depending on circumstance, but by which we are also inevitably constrained. (5)
Notwithstanding the above disclaimer, Jouannet says shortly afterwards that, among the large number of philosophers who have influenced Koskenniemi, the one who may be closest to him is Wittgenstein. (6) In addition, Jouannet, herself an academically-trained philosopher, makes a rather philosophical point which his important for any reflection on Koskenniemi's work. There is discussion among contemporary philosophers about the possibility of intersubjectivity being attained. However, the position of Koskenniemi remains that 'the practice of intersubjectivity inevitably becomes a simple argumentative strategy for claiming objectivity and thus a struggle to ensure the hegemony of one's personal position'. (7)
It is equally possible to describe such a position--whether or not it understands itself as philosophical--as simply obstinacy or intransigence, to use Wittgensteinian 'ordinary language'. It marks what 'ordinary people' might characterise as 'emotional immaturity', endless squabbling about whatever. At the same time, Jouannet notes that in the context of legal discourse, Koskenniemi is insisting that 'the solution to legal questions stems from a political decision and not from a reasoned choice'. (8) She goes on to quote Koskenniemi himself as saying that
[t]he decision always comes about, as a political theorist Ernesto Laclau has put it, as a kind of 'regulated madness', never reducible to any structure outside it. A court's decision or a lawyer's opinion is always a genuinely political act, a choice between alternatives not fully dictated by external criteria. It is even a hegemonic act in the precise sense that though it is partial and subjective, it claims to be universal and objective. (9)
This authoritarian, irrationalist discourse by its very nature cannot be contested because, at every stage, Koskenniemi deals in what is to him self-evidently an attempt to gain hegemonic control. Obviously whoever disagrees with him is simply trying to 'silence' him, to impose his own 'partial' view on …
Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Publication information: Article title: Language Games of International Law: Koskenniemi as the Discipline's Wittgenstein. Contributors: Carty, Anthony - Author. Journal title: Melbourne Journal of International Law. Volume: 13. Issue: 2 Publication date: November 2012. Page number: 859+. © Not available. COPYRIGHT 2012 Gale Group.
This material is protected by copyright and, with the exception of fair use, may not be further copied, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means.