Books: A Long, Hot Summer of Betrayal ; Hester Lacey Talks to Novelist Alexander Stuart about Tim Roth's New Film of His Book 'The War Zone', and the Events That Led Him to Write Such a Bleak Vision of Family Life
Lacey, Hester, The Independent (London, England)
Alexander Stuart did not set out to write a harrowing tale of child abuse and incest when he first planned The War Zone. His original idea was simply to write a novel round the concept of the family, following the birth of his son, Joe. "I wanted to write a positive book," he says wryly. "But it gradually got darker and darker." Two things altered his original notion. Firstly, during his researches, many of the interviews he carried out made grim hearing. "I started talking to women about their relationships with their fathers and came up with some really intense material. One woman had spent her childhood wishing her mother dead so she could sleep with her dad. Everything in the book, even the weirdest stuff, is true."
The second factor was Joe's illness. Stuart had written about a third of the book when his son was diagnosed with a rare form of cancer. Joe died at the age of five after a two-year illness. The War Zone was completed while Joe was dying, and this, says Stuart, made his writing reckless, as he worked in snatches between his son's chemotherapy sessions. "It's the only time in my life that writing came fast. I didn't want to waste any time. I would race back to the flat while Joe was sleeping for a few hours. It somehow made me fearless; whatever flaws the book may have, it was written with a real commitment to being as honest as possible. I wanted to push it as far as I could. It scared the hell out of me. When I wrote the ending, that wasn't how I had planned to resolve the book - the end almost wrote itself. It was weird."
As the book progressed, Stuart began to find the topic increasingly fascinating and abhorrent at the same time. "I find it so hard to understand how parents can abuse their children. One of the great joys of parenthood is holding your child's hand and exploring the world with them; how you can bring a child into the world and go from that to fondling your child sexually and abusing them is beyond me. I can understand to some degree how physical abuse might happen, how someone might hit out, though that doesn't excuse it, but sexual abuse is something else."
The War Zone, reissued on 9 September to coincide with the release of Tim Roth's film of the book, was controversial from the start. Set one long, hot summer in Devon, the book is written from the point of view of Tom, a teenager who discovers that his sister Jessie is having a sexual relationship with their father. Tom's anguish and despair as he realises the deceit and ugliness that lie beneath his family's outwardly respectable middle-class facade drive him to desperation; the family pulls itself apart. In 1989, when it was first published, the book won the Whitbread Award - but was then withdrawn because one of the jurors found it so "repellent" that she complained to the organisers.
The film remains true to the book in its uncompromising portrayal of a bleak subject. Tim Roth took the unusual step of asking Stuart to write the screenplay of his own book. "It's very rare that happens," says Stuart. "Tim never actually told me this, but he has written that he was quite prepared to replace me as writer if it didn't work out. One of the problems is that authors can be very precious about their own work. We stripped The War Zone right down to the essentials - I've always felt films should be different from books, you should take the essence of the book and work with that." A classic example, he says, is Apocalypse Now and Heart of Darkness.
Also, Stuart admires directors like Robert Altman who encourage improvisation, which is unusual for a writer. "When I write dialogue, I'm not particularly concerned that the exact dialogue is spoken; if someone is more comfortable saying something that has the same sense or even a different sense, that's fine," he says. …