Chapter 4Policy assessment or policy evaluation is an essential stage in policy analysis. There are several approaches in evaluating policies.
1 One of these approaches tends to emphasize the outcome of a certain policy and to what
extent it is in congruent with the stated objectives of that policy. For instance, Peters2 argues that policy evaluation should be based on identification of clear goals and measurement of the extent to which such goals have
been attained. Another approach tends to focus on the impact of a certain
policy, in so doing this approach tends to focus on impact assessment as a
tool for policy evaluation. For example, according to Dye,
3 policy evaluation is concerned with assessing the impact or consequences of public policy.
Recognizing the problems surrounding stated policy goals and the actual
policy goals in the first approach and the methodological difficulties in measuring the impact of a certain policy of the second approach, Matthew Cahn
developed a six-element index to evaluate policy success that addresses policy
coverage, implementation, and outcomes.
4 In evaluating environmental
policy in Egypt, I will use some of Cahn's indicators that are relevant to the Egyptian Society. Those indicators are as follows:
|• ||To what extent does environmental policy treat environmental problems and regulations in an independent and comprehensive way?|
|• ||To what extent does policy encourage behavior changes both on corporate and individual levels?|
|• ||To what extent does policy employ rational strategic mechanisms to
|• ||To what extent does compliance help maximize implementation potential?|
|• ||To what extent have/will these policies result in the anticipated outcomes?|
Questia, a part of Gale, Cengage Learning. www.questia.com
Book title: Environmental Policy Making in Egypt.
Contributors: Salwa Sharawi Jum ah - Author.
Publisher: University Press of Florida.
Place of publication: Gainesville, FL.
Publication year: 1997.
Page number: 54.
This material is protected by copyright and, with the exception of fair use, may
not be further copied, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means.