5 Old Wine in New Bottles--The Borderline Child Revisited: Contemporary Perspectives on Diagnosis and Assessment This chapter focuses on the borderline child in order to accomplish several interrelated objectives. First, I reconsider our thinking in relation to etiolog- ical factors, moving more in the assumptive direction that this disorder is in many instances related to exogenous, environmental factors (i.e., various forms of abuse and neglect), subsumed under Terr's ( 1991) Type II trauma, rather than reflecting a primary etiological base related to endogenous, in- ternal influences and conflict, which is the more traditional perspective ( Kernberg, 1975; Mahler et al., 1975; Masterson & Rinsley, 1975). Second, I illustrate how psychological test material often transcends other diagnostic information (e.g., interviews, behavioral observations, and rating scales), in providing for a comprehensive perspective regarding developmental functioning, especially in relation to ego functioning and object relations capacity. Third, in a related vein, I arrive at a more complete appreciation and sense of how psychological test data is utilized in the final formulation, with a particular emphasis on how TAT and Rorschach material--viewed primarily via an idiographic and phenomenological perspective--informs and guides treatment decisions and direction. Our current diagnostic nomenclature, DSM-IV, still does not easily pro- vide a clear place for the borderline child, a foster child or stepchild in many respects. Disruptive, primitive, aggressive, hyperactive, labile, disorga- nized, withdrawn, and so on, he or she may be diagnosed, or better still, pi- geonholed, in accord with criteria that accurately describe manifest behavior and symptomatology, but that fail to recognize central motiva- tional dynamics and etiological concerns. Frequently referred for severe -93- |