George Washington and the Origins of the American Presidency

George Washington and the Origins of the American Presidency

George Washington and the Origins of the American Presidency

George Washington and the Origins of the American Presidency

Synopsis

This essay collection is a retrospective analysis of the Washington administration and an examination of its importance to understanding the modern presidency. Contemporary presidential scholarship gives little attention to the enormous impact that Washington's actions had on establishing the presidency. Many of Washington's precedents last to this day, and in some respects his presidency established a model of leadership that is quite relevant today.

Excerpt

Thomas Engeman and Raymond Tatalovich

David K. Nichols (1994) has stirred interest among presidency scholars by arguing that the Founders intended a strong executive similar to that, in fact, created in the twentieth century. Moreover, the administration of George Washington—whom he calls the first ‘‘modern’’ president—realized in practice most of the essential features of the strong, modern executive.

Nichols is wise to draw attention to the actual, real executive power under Article ii of the Constitution. As Hamilton wrote in The Federalist: ‘‘Energy in the executive is a leading character of good government.’’ Moreover, Washington and Hamilton went very far in realizing the stated and the implied or prerogative powers of the Constitution. Indeed, the Washington administration should remain for us one of the great examples of the truly Constitutional use of executive powers. But there are problems connecting the Washington/Hamilton understanding of the strong executive with the modern understanding and reality.

Our rebuttal of Nichols’ thesis is organized in three parts. in Part I we summarize the essentials of the Nichols thesis. in Part ii we offer a theoretical counterargument that the ‘‘modern’’ understanding of the presidency originates not with the Constitutional Founding but from the Second American Constitution beginning with the Progressive critique and culminating in the mid-twentieth century. in Part iii we give experiential and empirical support for our interpretation by revisiting four presidential roles discussed by Nichols: foreign policy making, legislative leadership, administrative responsibility, and personalized leadership. Only with respect to diplomacy can President Washington be rightfully considered the ‘‘first’’ modern president, because he did, in fact, establish all the vital precedents of that role. But the reasons underlying this unique impact of Washington have as much

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.