Straight Science? Homosexuality, Evolution and Adaptation

Straight Science? Homosexuality, Evolution and Adaptation

Straight Science? Homosexuality, Evolution and Adaptation

Straight Science? Homosexuality, Evolution and Adaptation

Synopsis

The paradox of the 'gay' gene and Darwin's ideas on successful reproduction have led the author to the interesting conundrum of the evolutionary usefulness and advantage to homosexuality. This provokes questions that few dare to consider or even ask.

Excerpt

At the risk of entirely blowing my credibility at the outset, let me start this speculative look at male homosexuality by saying that it is written by a straight researcher who is less interested in explaining homosexuality, or in passing comment on it as a lifestyle, than in the perspective of a theorist confronted with an enormous difficulty threatening the tidy order of his theoretical universe. Homosexuality is a major problem for those like myself who believe that Darwinism is the great unifying force which social theory, particularly psychology, so desperately needs for internal coherence. Unfortunately, few would agree and there are many challenges to a Darwinistic view of the social order. Perhaps one of the cleverest challenges to confront evolutionary theory is homosexuality. Homosexuality seems to be a tailor-made rebuttal of the great evolutionary credo-survival of the fittest. How do we explain what is often a lifelong preference for non-reproductive sex? Surely homosexuality defies evolutionary explanation?

This is a clever criticism. While far from being a life against nature, homosexuality seems to contradict the Darwinian logic of individual reproductive success. Yet any number of surveys tell us that there are many homosexuals, and history attests to homosexuality's antiquity. If homosexuality is 'futile' sex, why are gay men still with us? Despite the weight of a historical bad press, which sees homosexuality as a pathological inversion of normal heterosexuality, its continuance suggests it is an adaptive feature of evolution. What selective advantages might homosexuals enjoy? How is such a widespread social behaviour to be explained? In this book we set out to answer these and other questions from an evolutionary perspective. While many would argue that Darwinism adds little to our understanding of homosexuality, nevertheless, causation is an intriguing puzzle and, if a diverse gay literature is any guide, is often a source of confusion for homosexuals themselves. Apart from being a purely intellectual puzzle, these questions also touch on much broader issues about the nature of biosocial research.

If the genesis of a book arises from dissatisfaction, mine was pro-

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.