Judging Evil: Rethinking the Law of Murder and Manslaughter

Judging Evil: Rethinking the Law of Murder and Manslaughter

Judging Evil: Rethinking the Law of Murder and Manslaughter

Judging Evil: Rethinking the Law of Murder and Manslaughter


The Sinai peninsula--a fabled triangle of land squeezed between Africa and Asia--harbors a rich deposit of cultural history. For many centuries, Sinai has served as a pivotal transit station, a lively route of caravans, armies, missionaries, and pilgrimages, and a military shield for Egypt. Sinai is also known as the crossroads of the world's three major religions: the site of Moses' exodus, it has subsequently been the entry point for Christianity's and Islam's spread into Africa and Asia.

Formerly isolated from the Egyptian mainland, Sinai is today poised on the threshold of new era. After regaining Sinai from Israel, Egypt encouraged Sinai's integration with the motherland, emphasizing its potential for tourism. Sinai: The Site and the History accordingly provides a point of reference from which this land can be discovered and rediscovered.

The work of a distinguished group of journalists and scholars, with over 60 stunning color photographs, Sinai provides a comprehensive picture of the region: its breathtaking geography, its remarkable secular and religious history, and the culture and customs of its Bedouin peoples.


Twenty years ago, when I was a newspaper reporter in Jacksonville, Florida, I reported on a case that I have never forgotten. It was one of those cases that comes along every so often that affects everyone it touches. At times it seemed to touch the whole city.

The facts were horrific. A father was convicted of the terrible abuse of his four children, abuse so severe that it killed two of them and left another battered and nearly blind. During a six-month period when his wife—who had been the main target of his abuse—was in jail, the heavy-set man with a brutal temper kicked, punched, and slapped his children who ranged from three to eleven years old. As punishments he jammed their small heads in a flushing toilet, beat and kicked them, breaking their limbs and causing internal injuries; he scraped his fingernails on the insides of their mouths, and on and on. Two of the children died of the abuse. Finally the eldest boy escaped and the father fled the city leaving his youngest daughter at a hospital with two dollars, her Teddy bear, and a note pinned to her clothes bearing the name and telephone number of her grandmother.

At the time I was influenced by the liberal creed of the sixties which decried harsh punishment, but as I listened to this tale of horrors, so much worse than any fiction, I found myself agreeing with the state, that these acts deserved severe punishment. Surely if anyone deserved the death penalty it must be this Ernest John Dobbert Jr.

Then I met Dobbert 's defense attorney, one of the most perceptive observers of the criminal justice system I have ever encountered, and heard the testimony he offered at a resentencing hearing. Dobbert was the son of an abusive father who beat and degraded him. The son so feared his father that to avoid his learning about a bad grade, Dobbert Jr. once cut the telephone wires to the house. The defense evidence suggested that Dobbert Jr. was caught in a cycle of abuse far beyond his power to control. In a strange way . . .

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.