Harry S. Truman and the Cold War Revisionists

Harry S. Truman and the Cold War Revisionists

Harry S. Truman and the Cold War Revisionists

Harry S. Truman and the Cold War Revisionists

Synopsis

The idea of revising what is known of the past constitutes an essential procedure in historical scholarship, but revisionists are often hasty and argumentative in their judgments. Such, argues Robert H. Ferrell, has been the case with assessments of the presidency of Harry S. Truman, who was targeted by historians and political scientists in the 1960s and '70s for numerous failings in both domestic and foreign policy, including launching the cold war-perceptions that persist to the present day. Widely acknowledged as today's foremost Truman scholar, Ferrell turns the tables on the revisionists in this collection of classic essays. He goes below the surface appearances of history to examine how situations actually developed and how Truman performed sensibly-even courageously-in the face of unforeseen crises. While some revisionists see Truman as consumed by a blind hatred of the Soviet Union and adopting an unrestrainedly militant stance, Ferrell convincingly shows that Truman wished to get along with the Soviets and was often bewildered by their actions. He interprets policies such as the Truman Doctrine, the Marshall Plan, and support for NATO as prudent responses to perceived threats and credits the Truman administration for the ways in which it dealt with unprecedented problems. What emerges most vividly from Ferrell's essays is a sense of how weak a hand the United States held from 1945 to1950, with its conventional forces depleted by the return of veterans to civil pursuits after the war and with its capacity for delivery of nuclear weapons in a sorry state. He shows that Truman regarded the atomic bomb as a weapon of last resort, not an instrument of policy, and that he took America into a war in Korea for the good of the United States and its allies. Although Truman has been vindicated on many of these issues, there still remains a lingering controversy over the use of atomic weapons in Japan-a decision that Ferrell argues is understandable in light of what Truman faced at the start of his presidency. Ferrell argues that the revisionists who attacked Truman understood neither the times nor the man-one of the most clearheaded, farsighted presidents ever to occupy the Oval Office. Harry S. Truman and the Cold War Revisionists shows us that Truman's was indeed a remarkable presidency, as it cautions historians against too quickly appraising the very recent past.

Excerpt

Every now and then a notion or idea arises that is radically wrong. Such was the case when years ago a large group of historians and political scientists known as revisionists undertook to criticize the foreign policy of President Harry S. Truman. The group flourished in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Its adherents saw Truman as the originator of the troubles between the United States and Russia, the cold war that began after World War II and lasted until the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991.

There is nothing wrong, let me add hastily, with the notion or idea of revisionism, taken by itself. My generation of historians, who began their studies in the years just after the war of 1941-1945, read and appreciated the essays of the best-known historian of the time, Charles A. Beard, who declared that revision was the essence of scholarship. We were fascinated by the similar wisdom of Carl L. Becker of Cornell University, who spoke of [every man his own historian,] showing how out of a desire to learn about the past we all change our memory if it proves faulty. We are all revisionists.

But the cold war revisionists who attacked President Truman did not understand the time in which he was president nor the man himself. They did not believe that after entrance of the United States into World . . .

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.