A Style of History for Beginners

A Style of History for Beginners

A Style of History for Beginners

A Style of History for Beginners

Excerpt

Are there standards of historical thinking that a teacher can put before beginning students, to show them how to handle data so as to reach sound historical judgments? Certainly the styles of history produced by acknowledged masters follow no one pattern: this is well shown in the collection of representative statements recently edited by Fritz Stern as The Varieties of History.* Some leading historians have long felt that the qualities of good history, whatever they are, cannot be taught explicitly. Students even when born with the necessary insight, the contention is, can only absorb these standards through years of practice on historical materials.

But this seems talk about an unattainable level of craftmanship, for teachers who, each September, face classes containing potentially serious beginning students. Many of these promising students --as some of us have painfully learned by now--will have no real patience with class discussions that fritter away in empty or inconclusive talk. I should therefore like to report what are taught as standards for historical thinking in one large freshman course where students come with no previous interest in history but respond to it quickly and with satisfaction when it is presented in terms of these definite standards.

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.