Schools of Asceticism: Ideology and Organization in Medieval Religious Communities

Schools of Asceticism: Ideology and Organization in Medieval Religious Communities

Schools of Asceticism: Ideology and Organization in Medieval Religious Communities

Schools of Asceticism: Ideology and Organization in Medieval Religious Communities

Synopsis

A sociological study of religious ascetical groups in the later Middle Ages.

Max Weber argued that medieval religious movements were an important source for the distinctive rationality of Western civilization. He intended to study precisely this theme but died before he could do so. In Schools of Asceticism, Lutz Kaelber builds on Weber's ideas by presenting a fresh historical and theoretical analysis of orthodox and heretical religious groups in the Middle Ages. He explores how doctrine and social organization shaped ascetic conduct in these groups from the twelfth century on.

Kaelber first examines monastic and mendicant groups, correcting common misperceptions about the nature of their ascetic practices and their significance for the emergence of a Protestant work ethic. Then he turns to two of the largest and most widespread heretical groups in the Middle Ages, the Waldensians and the Cathars. For the most part, Waldensians and Cathars practiced a form of "other-worldly asceticism" resembling that of monks and nuns. For the Austrian Waldensians, however, Kaelber documents a type of "inner-worldly asceticism" that resembled what Weber described for early modern Protestant groups. Both types of asceticism originated in distinctive heretical establishments: Waldensian schools and Cathar "houses of heretics." As these establishments disappeared, the boundaries separating Waldensianism and Catharism from Catholicism collapsed. Kaelber is therefore able to link organizational aspects of heretical communities to the tenacity of heresy in the Middle Ages.

Based on exhaustive research into both primary and secondary sources, Schools of Asceticism is a bold and original book thatbridges the disciplines of comparative historical and theoretical sociology, medieval history, and religious studies.

Excerpt

Monastic asceticism and its role in the development of Western rationalism have been a contentious topic in historical and sociological scholarship ever since its classical thematization by Weber and Troeltsch. the classical view, in which medieval monasticism was important for its asceticism and valorization of labor but remained other-worldly, has not gone unchallenged. An alternative has been proposed by scholars who, assessing the role of monasticism in Western history differently, have argued for a much stronger rationalizing impact of monastic asceticism. the central contention of this revisionist account is that monastic asceticism led to important rationalizations in the medieval economy and technology. the church, in the alternative view, was instrumental in bringing about technological innovations in the Middle Ages and in advancing capitalism.

In this chapter, I analyze the links between medieval monasticism and asceticism in light of newer historical and sociological scholarship, and assess the merits of both classical and revisionist accounts by probing the extent to which monasticism was linked to forms of work that served as a worldly avenue of asceticism. the analysis demonstrates that monasticism, while in theory valorizing work as ascetic practice, increasingly specialized in providing conspicuous religious services for . . .

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.