Academic journal article Canadian Journal of History

Mishandled Vessels: Heaving Drinks and Hurling Insults in Medieval Welsh Literature and Law

Academic journal article Canadian Journal of History

Mishandled Vessels: Heaving Drinks and Hurling Insults in Medieval Welsh Literature and Law

Article excerpt

The mid-thirteenth-century Welsh legal codex NLW Latin ms Peniarth 28 (fig. 1) is famous as much for its illustrations as its content, especially the picture of two men locked in a hair-pulling tussle. (1) Not surprisingly, the picture illustrates sarhaed, a term that means both insult and redress and which occurs repeatedly in medieval Welsh literature and law. (2) Welsh law treats many forms of insult, in many places, all of which require compensation. Welsh literature describes numerous actions that demand redress, some of which directly echo scenarios described in the laws. In effect, this depiction exemplifies aspects of feud that lie behind legal and literary descriptions of sarhaed. The near identical participants suggest an equality of status, and seem to imply that "what goes around comes around"--each could just as easily be the victim or aggressor. Welsh Law contains commentary on social order, hierarchy and proper behaviour, and this is reflected in the Arthurian tales Peredur and Owein, which illustrate to some extent the principles behind the laws in action. (3) The laws, alongside the tales, shed light on the values of the society that produced that literature, and this helps elucidate how the tales make meaning. Taken together, all three examples--tales, law texts, and picture--point out the mentalite which lies behind the transaction of honour and power in medieval Welsh society.

I. Feud

Medieval men and women took their insults much more seriously than perhaps we do, and often comments or gestures, whether unintentional or calculated, could spark a violent blood feud. Today, the term feud carries negative connotations: there is a current western cultural bias against groups who practice self-help violence associated with insult and redress, but to the participants in the feuding process, such violence functioned as a "... reasonable and eminently moral form of social action." (4)

Feud can be engendered by insult and once begun, is itself treated as a form of insult requiring reparation. In essence, feud is aggressive social competition integral to the creation and maintenance of social order. Feud is motivated by scarcity, both material and moral, and takes the form of a game played between relative equals who keep score and endeavour to take the lead from one another. (5) This game of exchanges is potentially interminable, but the understanding of a never-ending conflict motivates the parties involved to limit their conflict. Still, even after a resolution, any affront or assault will likely spark additional hostilities. (6) It is this concept of talion that accounts for the cyclical nature of insult and redress in Welsh literature and law. Simply put, any act that brings about dishonour must be somehow either atoned for or paid back. Finally, feud is driven by the participants' belief that their honour has somehow been threatened or compromised. "The feud was more than the series of overt actions that made it up," according to one scholar. "It was the relationship between the groups, the state of the participants' minds, the postures of defiance, antagonism, and coldness filling the intervals of time between hostile confrontations. These things were every bit as much a part of the feud as vengeance killing." (7)

The single most important factor which informs the mentalite of feud cultures, the fundamental characteristic of feud which cuts across temporal and geographic boundaries, is the need to acquire and defend the intangible commodity of honour. Feud, therefore, occurs where institutions of governance are weak or absent. It is driven by scarcity of material and moral resources, and is a potentially interminable game played between equals.

II. Texts (8)

In the tale of Peredur, the hero, clad in threadbare rags and mounted on a bony nag, arrives at the court of Arthur seeking to be knighted. Immediately prior to his coming, a knight-errant had approached Arthur's court and snatched a wine-filled goblet from the hand of the queen, emptying the liquor over her face and breast, and giving her a great box on the ear. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.