Academic journal article Policy Review

The Inequity of the Progressive Income Tax

Academic journal article Policy Review

The Inequity of the Progressive Income Tax

Article excerpt

Class Wars: A Parable

ONCE UPON a time in the land of America, there lived triplet brothers named Tom, Dick, and Harry Class. They were 4 5 years old, had virtually the same aptitude (skill), and were raised in the same home. Each was married and had two children. All three were employed as carpenters making $ 2 5 per hour, working 50 weeks a year.

While they were almost identical in most respects, they had somewhat different preferences and values. For example, Tom, who worked 20 hours a week, had a different work ethic from his brothers, Dick and Harry, who each worked 60 hours per week. Neither Tom's nor Dick's wives worked, while Harry's wife worked 40 hours per week as an office manager making $50,000 per year (the same hourly rate as her husband). Tom and Dick spent all of their income, and were relying on Social Security to take care of them when they retired. Harry and his wife, on the other hand, saved most of her after-tax income over many years, gradually accumulating $300,000. They invested this money in bonds and real estate that produced $25,000 a year in interest and rental income. This was the income of each family:

                               Family

                        Tom     Dick      Harry

Work hours per Week:    20       60        100

Annual Wages
  Husband:            $25,000  $75,000   $75,000
  Wife:                     0        0    50,000

Investment Income:          0        0    25,000

Total Income:         $25,000  $75,000  $150,000

Despite their different priorities, the Class families were close; so much so that when a new housing tract was developed in their community, they each bought an equal-priced home on the same private street. Theirs were the only houses on the street.

One day the brothers decided to pool their funds for the purpose of improving their street. Concerned about crime and safety, and desirous of a more attractive setting for their homes, the three families decided to: install a gate at the street's entrance to deter burglars; add lighting for safety and additional security; repave the street's surface to repair damage; and install landscaping to beautify the approach to their homes. The work was done for a total cost of $30,000.

The brothers were quite happy with the outcome and felt the $30,000 was a worthy expenditure given the benefits provided each family. But when it came time to divide up the bill, the problems began.

Harry thought it would be simple to divide the bill. Since the benefits to each family were equal, each brother should pay one-third, or about $10,000. But Tom and Dick objected. "Why should we pay the same as you?" they said. "You make much more money than we do." Harry was puzzled. "Why is that relevant?" he asked. "My family makes more money than yours does because my wife and I work long hours and we earn extra money on our savings. Why should we be penalized for working and saving?" Harry looked at Tom and said, "I'm no smarter or more talented than you are. If you and your wife worked harder and saved more you would make as much as my family does." To which Tom replied, "I don't work more because I value my leisure time more than I value money. And I don't save because I prefer the gratification of consumption today more than I will when I'm too old to enjoy it." Tom was adamant. How could Harry, who was clearly "rich," ask him to pay the same amount, when it was obviously harder for him to do so?

Dick thought for a moment, and then said, "I've got an idea. Our aggregate income is $250,000, and $30,000 is 12 percent of that amount. Why don't we each pay that percentage of our income? Under that formula, Tom would owe $3,000, I would owe $9,000, and Harry would owe $18,000. Since I make three times as much as Tom, I would pay three times as much. Harry, who makes twice as much as me and six times as much as Tom would pay two times as much as me and six times as much as Tom. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.