The Convergent Validity of Two Sensory Processing Scales Used with School-Age Children: Comparing the Sensory Profile and the Sensory Processing Measure

Article excerpt

Sensory processing problems can often negatively impact on a child's occupational performance. For example, the limited range of foods a child will eat, sensitivity to certain types of clothing textures, low tolerance for noisy environments, and aversion to being hugged. Occupational therapists have a key role in assessing the sensory needs of children. Sensory processing scales used with school-age children include the Sensory Profile (Dunn, 1999), the Sensory Profile School Companion (SPSC) (Dunn, 2006), and the Sensory Processing Measure (SPM) (Miller-Kuhaneck, Henry, Glennon, & Mu, 2007; Parham, Ecker, Miller-Kuhananeck, Henry, & Glennon, 2007). These scales are all standardized parent-report, teacher-report, judgment-based questionnaires that require the respondent to complete a rating scale based on how frequently certain behaviours occur. For any standardized test, it important that a body of psychometric evidence is established, particularly studies completed by independent investigators, in addition to the studies completed by the original test authors (Anastasi & Urbina, 1997; Downing, 2003; Streiner & Norman, 1995). Since the scales under investigation are all relatively new, additional empirical studies documenting their reliability and validity are needed (Baranek, 2002; Goodwin, 2002; Kielhofner, 2006).

The purpose of this study is to examine the convergent validity of the Sensory Profile, the SPSC, and the Home and Main Classroom Forms of the SPM. The specific research questions are: i) what is the convergent validity of the SPM--Home Form and the Sensory Profile?; ii) what is the convergent validity of the SPM--Main Classroom Form and the SPSC?; and iii) what is the association between the ratings of mothers of children who complete the Sensory Profile and the SPM--Home Form and the ratings of teachers of the same children who complete the SPSC and the SPM--Main Classroom Form?

The Sensory Profile, the SPSC, and the SPM were all developed in the United States, but are used by therapists in New Zealand and Australia as well as other Western countries (Rodger, Brown, & Brown, 2006; Rodger, Brown, Brown, & Roever, 2006). Completing studies in a cross cultural context provides valuable data about the relevance, usability, and applicability of the scales (Brown, Leo, & Austin, 2008; Streiner & Norman, 1995). Information regarding convergent validity is currently lacking with the Sensory Profile, SPSC, and the SPM (Fairbank, 2005; Miller-Kuhaneck et al., 2007).

Literature review

Sensory processing is a neurological process that occurs in all of us. Sensory input from the environment and from the body itself provides information to the brain (Dunn, 2007). The brain organizes, integrates, synthesizes, and uses this information to understand experiences and organize appropriate responses. The processing of information allows individuals to respond automatically, efficiently, and comfortably in response to the specific sensory inputs received (Dunn, 2007; Yack, Aquilla, & Sutton, 2002). Sensory processing skills influence a child's ability to perform everyday tasks and activities (occupations), and therefore they are used by occupational therapists for specific assessment, intervention, monitoring, and follow-up evaluation (Case-Smith, Richardson, & Schultz-Krohn, 2005; Yack et al., 2002).

Sensory processing disorder

Sometimes a child's response to the sensory environment can have a negative impact on the successful engagement with and completion of his/her daily life occupations. Sensory processing disorders (SPD) "affects the way the brain interprets the information that comes in and the response that follows, causing emotional, motor, and other reactions that are inappropriate and extreme" (Bowyer & Cahill, 2009, p. 331). Reduced ability to play successfully with other children can be related to poor participation in sensory and motor play, from which cognitive and social skills emerge and develop (Bundy, 2002). …


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.