Academic journal article The Hastings Center Report

Health Care and the Presidential Election

Academic journal article The Hastings Center Report

Health Care and the Presidential Election

Article excerpt

Many Republicans and Democrats in Washington see health care as capable of challenging the slim Republican majority in the House. But how will it play as a presidential campaign issue?

The candidates for the White House are playing to a public that cares a lot about health care, but doesn't understand how the current system works. Consider these two polls. Last year, an Employee Benefits Research Institute survey showed that 62 percent of people in preferred provider organizations or point of service plans didn't even know they were in managed care. And in May, a poll released by the Kaiser Family Foundation found that a majority of Americans care about the uninsured, but that there was no consensus about a solution.

What's a presidential candidate to do?

Al Gore is braving the details. During Gore's race with Bill Bradley for the presidential nomination, he countered Bradley's total revamping of Medicaid with a plan to beef up the present system.

George W. Bush is taking a quieter approach. His first speech devoted to health care didn't come until mid-April, and he's basing his proposals on private insurance. He's proposed a $41.6 billion package of tax credits and incentives to help lower-income families purchase insurance, and he's said he would give $4.3 billion to inner cities and rural areas to create health clinics.

Bush is stuck with a problematic record as governor of Texas. In a New York Times article that is a must-read for anyone charting Bush's health record, Adam Clymer vivisects the governor. Saying Bush "has not made health care a priority," Clymer points to Texas's unenviable uninsured rate of 27.5 percent and reports his Texas health commissioner's comment that lack of insurance isn't a major problem because even uninsured people get medical care. The commissioner has also been quoted as saying that teen pregnancy is high among Hispanics because it's acceptable in that community and that doctors don't support preventive care because it will hurt their practices.

While Gore may be talking more about health care than Bush, his recent record is less tangible. There was, of course, the failed Clinton health plan, but Gore has managed to avoid association with that. He is linking himself instead with Clinton's plan to provide prescription drug benefits as a separate insurance policy for older people in Medicare. And he has held some high-profile events to bring attention to that plan, such as going to a Connecticut pharmacy with a Medicare recipient struggling to afford the dozen drugs she needs. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.