Academic journal article Journal of Applied Management and Entrepreneurship

Design for Industrial Product-Services Combinations-A Literature Review

Academic journal article Journal of Applied Management and Entrepreneurship

Design for Industrial Product-Services Combinations-A Literature Review

Article excerpt


During the last decade, a shift in many manufacturing industries has occurred; equipment suppliers are turning into solution providers to stay competitive. Especially when competing with low-cost competitors (Baines et al., 2007), they are changing from merely selling customers their capital goods products in favor of offering them a combination of products and services. This combination of products with services is commonly termed a product-services system. In theory and practice, the basic principles of this transition to providing services along with industrial products (e.g. Wise & Baumgartner, 1999; Mont, 2004) have been discussed intensively. This transition has necessitated corresponding organizational changes (e.g. Oliva & Kallenberg, 2003) as well as rethinking pricing and controlling issues (e.g. Reichwald & Wegner, 2008).

The newly arising technological requirements to accommodate the services aspects of the industrial equipment have been largely disregarded. "Companies often lack knowledge and experience in actually developing solutions that are economically feasible" (Tan & McAloone, 2006, p. 1). One reason might be that up to now no comprehensive set of design rules for the products used in productservices combinations has been developed. Although a large variety of design guidelines exist, with only a few exceptions (Sundin & Bras, 2005; Doultsinou, Roy, Baxter, Gao & Mann, 2009; Sundin, Lindahl & Ijomah, 2009), these have not been related to the combination of industrial products with services. The developments of new services and of new products are not independent but, in product-services combinations, these must be considered together as inter-dependent (Kindström & Kowalkowski, 2009).

Adapting products to the emerging requirements for services is necessary to tap the full potential of industrial services. In industrial senices, some risks are shifted from customer to the producer or supplier (Aurich, Fuchs & Wagenknecht, 2006) of the industrial good. Property rights of the physical assets used are retained by the producer in use-oriented and result-oriented product-services combinations. An industrial services provider will seek to reduce the costs of the services performed as they represent extra costs that producers not providing such services do not have (Toffel, 2008). Design adaptations and innovations are means of cutting the costs of the combined product and services. Yet, neither design for sale-principles nor mere design-to-cost are sufficient any longer to ensure the competitiveness of the industrial companies that also offer services as part of their product.

The need for an integrated development of products and services in the first stages of the development of industrial services offerings has been recognized by several authors (e.g. WeIp, Meier, Sadek & Sadek, 2008; Tan & McAloone, 2006; Doultsinou et al., 2009). Modeling approaches to integrate services and products were used. Baines and his colleagues (2007) in their literature review of product-services system research found a range of tools and methodologies for the development of these concepts exist. They conclude, however, that these modeling tools lack completeness (Baines et al., 2007, p. 1550) and their performance in practice needs to be evaluated. In a more recent literature review on servitization, Baines and other colleagues (Baines, Lightfoot, Benedettini & Kay, 2009) repeat the earlier view by stating, "there is little work to date that can be used by practitioners (p. 547)."

On the other hand, there are a multitude of practice-oriented publications and compilations of design principles which support designers in the process of developing capital goods optimized for maintenance and servicing (e.g. Bralla, 1996). The services component of industrial services is more than these activities, however and detailed engineering guidelines and design notes for the technical equipment used in industrial product-services combinations are still lacking. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.