Academic journal article Pakistan Historical Society. Journal of the Pakistan Historical Society

A Federal Council

Academic journal article Pakistan Historical Society. Journal of the Pakistan Historical Society

A Federal Council

Article excerpt

In Pakistan and in India the trend towards increase of power by the federation has been reversed. It is now unmistakably towards greater power for the federating provinces or states.

This is a result of political changes rather than constitutional amendment by itself. The 18th Amendment to the Pakistan constitution was a product of political change.

Initially both federations emulated the federal structure established by the Government of India Act, 1935. Later, they followed different routes. Nowhere is this more apparent than in regard to the Inter-Provincial Council set up by Section 135 of the Act. It was blindly copied in Article 263 of the Indian constitution which was adopted by the Constituent Assembly without debate on June 13, 1949. It empowers the president to establish by an order an Inter-State Council charged with the duty of '(a) inquiring into and advising upon disputes which may have arisen between states; (b) investigating and discussing subjects in which some or all of the states, or the Union and one or more of the states, have a common interest; or (c) making recommendations upon any such subject and, in particular, recommendations for the better coordination of policy and action with respect to that subject.' The order could define its organisation and procedure as well as 'the nature of the duties to be performed by it' While a few bodies on specific subjects were set up, the Inter-State Council as envisaged by Article 263 was established in 1990, 40 years after the constitution was enacted. The order establishing the council emasculated it calculatedly. It could be convened only by the centre which would also lay down the agenda. Small wonder that it has failed to make the slightest impact on India's federal system.

Article Ï30 of the 1956 Pakistan constitution contained a similar provision but with two vital differences. The Inter Provincial Council could not be set upexcept 'with the consent of the governors of the provinces' and it could not concern itself with disputes between the provinces.

Section 135 of the Government of India Act 1935 was the considered product of deliberations on the proposed federation at the roundtable conferences in London. Para 226 of the report of the joint committee of both houses of the British parliament on Indian constitutional reform (1934) explained the raison d'etre of the council. There will be necessarily many subjects on which inter-provincial consultation will be necessary, as indeed has proved to be the case even at the present time; and we consider that every effort should be made to develop a system of interprovincial confederacies, at which administrative problems common to adjacent areas as well as points of difference may be discussed and adjusted.

There were 'a number of matters on which it is, in our view, important that the provinces should coordinate their policy... if departments or institutions of coordination and research are to be maintained at the centre in such matters as agriculture, forestry, irrigation, education and public health and if such institutions are to be able to rely on appropriations of public funds sufficient to enable them to cariy on their work, the joint interests of the provincial governments in them must be expressed in some regular and recognised machinery of inter-governmental consultation. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.