Academic journal article American Academic & Scholarly Research Journal

Talaat Pasha's Murder (15.3.1921): A Parody in the Courts of Berlin Belying 'The Miller of Sansoucci Legend of Justice'

Academic journal article American Academic & Scholarly Research Journal

Talaat Pasha's Murder (15.3.1921): A Parody in the Courts of Berlin Belying 'The Miller of Sansoucci Legend of Justice'

Article excerpt


The European Court of Human Rights' ECHR 370 Resolution dated 17.12.2013, relating to the case of Mr. Dogu Perincek versus Switzerland, received much publicity worldwide. The attention of 'scholars on international law' has been focused on this case, particularly when in mid- March 2014 Switzerland applied to the Higher Court for revision of the first verdict.

The year 1921, like every year between World War I and Adolf Hitler's rise to power, was for Germany one of gloom, Political life had not yet recovered from the shock caused by the overthrow of a form of government deeply rooted in the history of the people. The newly empowered Reichstag was prey to wild party strife, which made the formation of a stable government difficult.

The trial of the murder of Talat Pasha proved to be a most shameful comedy, because the killer Tehlarian was found innocent whilst the victim Talat Pasha was found guilty of killing Armenians previously in Turkey. The German Judges gave in to the Armenian and Victor's pressures.

Liman Von Sanders and the German Protestant pastor Dr. Johannes Lepsius deposed in the court as experts. Liman Von Sanders did not mentioned anything about the German Ambassador of the era and also him being the Commander in Chief of the Ottoman Army. He did not testify against Talaat but he also did not tell the truth in full extend but a quarter of it only. Accordingly his testimony was against rather than pro.

Although an appeal notice was sent to Bronsart Von Shellendorf, he wasn't called as a witness to the court. After the final verdict of the court, he published an article in a newspaper as a reaction to the court's verdict.

This paper, based on information excerpted from the non Turkish or non Ottoman formal documents and/or official releases, tries to bring into life what happened actually during the trial and the effect of the heavy and irresistible pressures on the German judges.

Keywords: Talaat Pasha, Ottoman, Armenian, Tehlarian, Murder, Berlin

1 Introduction

The Turkish group which calls the 'genocide' accusation 'an imperialistic lie', had taken the title of 'Talaat Pasha Committee'. Talaat Pasha was a minister of interior and later the Prime Minister of the Ottoman Government. Although he was known for his friendship with Armenians (until an assassin sent to kill him was caught), he was the one who was 'held personally responsible' for all of the wrong doings during the process of temporary 'relocation of some Armenians' to the safe zones where there was no war. This relocation inside the Empire was due to military obligation and was a necessity. It is a known fact, even admitted by the League of Nations General Secretary that 'Revolutionary Armenians' were hitting the back supply lines and engaging units of the army in acts of sabotages when they were needed in Gallipoli to fight against the Allied landings. The General Secretary of the League of Nations had written that 200.000 Armenians 'sacrificed their lives in their fights for the Entente' trusting the promises given which were not kept when the war had ended.

In reality Talaat Pasha was one of the three leaders of the Ottoman Government and merely had carried out the process regulated by law. This was executed 'for the first time in Ottoman history' by governors (valis) in the provinces where revolutionaries were hiding, feeding themselves and sabotaging the army.

General public may not be aware but the Armenian lobby in California has managed to have their own one sided version of genocide included in lectures in high schools of the State recently, thus raising a generation with full hatred of Turks and their children living in USA, all U.S. citizens. Nowadays, a similar effort is being made in Germany, based on the 'biased and very superficial knowledge of the German Community' about 'genocide'. This is derived from very effective Armenian propaganda and a sense of Solidarity, while believing in only what they hear or read selectively without cross examining other and neutral documentation. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.