Municipal Government

city government

city government, political administration of urban areas.

The English tradition of incorporating urban units (cities, boroughs, villages, towns) and allowing them freedom in most local matters is general in the United States (see city; local government). The traditional U.S. city government had a mayor and council, whose members (aldermen) represented districts (wards). As the complexity of urban life increased in the 19th cent., the old system became less efficient: problems included overlapping of old offices with new, poor methods of accounting and taxation, and much blatant graft.

From these abuses arose movements for municipal reform, which have become a recurrent feature of American political life. They have familiarized Americans with a gallery of such political figures as William M. Tweed of New York City, Frank Hague of Jersey City, and William Hale Thompson of Chicago (see bossism). Although the urban political machine has, in most cities, lost its former power, the traditional type of city government, also known as the independent executive type, remains the most common urban governmental form. It is often subdivided into the strong mayor type (e.g., New York City) and the weak mayor–strong council type (e.g., Los Angeles).

Reform efforts have resulted in the development of two fairly widespread alternative governmental types. The commission form has a board, both legislative and administrative, usually elected nonpartisan and at large. First adopted by Galveston, Tex. (1901), this system achieved great popularity in the early 1900s, but many cities (e.g., Buffalo and New Orleans) later abandoned it. The city manager plan gives the administration to one professional nonpolitical director. The system has gained in popularity; notable examples are in Staunton, Va., the first (1908) to adopt it, and Cincinnati, Ohio.

A perennial problem of U.S. urban government is the division of urban areas among several independent city governments, survivals of old separate communities. The Eastern metropolises all provide examples, aggravated in some (e.g., New York City and Philadelphia), where state lines run through the heart of the metropolitan area. Attempts at efficiency have produced such organizations as the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, a corporation set up by joint action of New York state and New Jersey, and assigned specific powers formerly held by local governments. Another problem besetting city government is the migration of middle-class families to the suburban areas, thus shrinking the tax base and financial resources of the cities.

In the rest of the English-speaking world and wherever else there is much local self-government, American forms and problems are paralleled. Elsewhere, as typically in France, the local officers, albeit elected mayor and councillors, are largely figureheads, serving mainly to carry out the regulations of the central bureaucracy.

See C. R. Adrian, Governing Urban America (4th ed. 1972). W. A. Robson and D. E. Regan, ed., Great Cities of the World (2 vol., 1972); M. David, Running City Hall (1982); C. R. Adrian, A History of American City Government: The Emergence of the Metropolis, 1920–1945 (1988); R. Suarez, The Old Neighborhood (1999).

The Columbia Encyclopedia, 6th ed. Copyright© 2014, The Columbia University Press.

Municipal Government: Selected full-text books and articles

Managing Urban America
David R. Morgan; Robert E. England.
Chatham House Publishers, 1999 (5th edition)
The Regional Governing of Metropolitan America
David Y. Miller.
Westview Press, 2002
FREE! City Government by Commission
Clinton Rogers Woodruff.
D. Appleton, 1911
The Rebirth of Urban Democracy
Jeffrey M. Berry; Kent E. Portney; Ken Thomson.
Brookings Institutuion, 1993
Official Leadership in the City: Patterns of Conflict and Cooperation
James H. Svara.
Oxford University Press, 1990
Local Government Information and Training Needs in the 21st Century
Jack P. Desario; Sue R. Faerman; James D. Slack.
Quorum Books, 1994
Taming City Hall: Rightsizing for Results
Gerald Seals.
Institute for Contemporary Studies, 1995
The Corporate City: The American City as a Political Entity, 1800-1850
Leonard P. Curry.
Greenwood, vol.1, 1997
The Ecology of City Policymaking
Robert J. Waste.
Oxford University Press, 1989
Governing Urban America: Structure, Politics, and Administration
Charles R. Adrian.
McGraw-Hill, 1955
Municipal Government and Administration
William Bennett Munro.
Macmillan, vol.2, 1923
The Mayors: The Chicago Political Tradition
Paul M. Green; Melvin G. Holli.
Southern Illinois University Press, 1995 (Revised edition)
The Evolution of E-Government among Municipalities: Rhetoric or Reality?
Moon, M. Jae.
Public Administration Review, Vol. 62, No. 4, July-August 2002
Peer-reviewed publications on Questia are publications containing articles which were subject to evaluation for accuracy and substance by professional peers of the article's author(s).
Reinventing Government: City Manager Attitudes and Actions
Kearney, Richard C.; Feldman, Barry M.; Scavo, Carmine P. F.
Public Administration Review, Vol. 60, No. 6, November 2000
Peer-reviewed publications on Questia are publications containing articles which were subject to evaluation for accuracy and substance by professional peers of the article's author(s).
Looking for a topic idea? Use Questia's Topic Generator


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.