Magazine article Sojourners Magazine

Regime Change in Haiti: The Bush Doctrine Strikes Again

Magazine article Sojourners Magazine

Regime Change in Haiti: The Bush Doctrine Strikes Again

Article excerpt

The violent overthrow of Haitian President Jean-Bertrand Aristide in late February should be cause of great concern--not because Aristide was any longer a friend of the poor or a bright shining hope for the people of Haiti. His own arrogant, corrupt, and autocratic ways had pushed him to the brink. But that's not why the Bush administration was happy to push him the rest of the way over the edge.

U.S. forces may not have literally "kidnapped" Aristide and forced him to leave the country at gun-point, as he claimed. But "call it what you will. The fact is the administration did nothing to save democracy in Haiti," Rep. William D. Delahunt told The Washington Post, And in that, U.S. authorities sent a "dangerous and irresponsible" message to the region that "this administration will not stand up for a democratically elected head of state they do not like," argued Rep. Robert Menendez.

The coup in Haiti, the world's first black independent state, may have been more artfully engineered than the regime change in Iraq, but the Bush team's fingerprints are over it. You don't even have to follow the money. Many of those responsible for Aristide's overthrow have blood splashed all across their resumes, back to the death squads of the 1980s and '90s and the brutal, U.S.-backed dictatorships of Papa and Baby Doc Duvalier.

That history goes a long way toward explaining Aristide's failure to solidify democracy or bring about economic development. Even if Aristide had had the stature and moral rectitude of a Nelson Mandela, success would still have been unlikely, given what he faced--U.S. financial and political support for an armed, unprincipled opposition; economic sanctions; a curtailment of much-needed humanitarian aid. It's not hard for an economic behemoth like the United States to ruin the economy of the hemisphere's poorest country.

HAITI'S 2004 COUP, the country's 32nd since it was founded 200 years ago, gave yet more evidence of the real meaning of the "Bush doctrine" of regime change. At heart, it's not about WMDs or human rights or legitimate governance. For the duly elected (albeit flawed) president of Haiti, it came down to: You're on our side, or you're gone. Human rights may be routinely ignored and elite corruption rampant from Saudi Arabia to Singapore, but as long as the countries' leaders are compliant to U. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.