Magazine article Newsweek

The Curse of the Show Killers; Is It Really Possible That the Mere Presence of Certain Actors or Actresses Can Doom a TV Show? Meet an Elite Cadre Who Are Living, and Often Thriving, despite Conspiracy Theories

Magazine article Newsweek

The Curse of the Show Killers; Is It Really Possible That the Mere Presence of Certain Actors or Actresses Can Doom a TV Show? Meet an Elite Cadre Who Are Living, and Often Thriving, despite Conspiracy Theories

Article excerpt

Byline: Marc Peyser (With Anne Taulane)

After years of breathing HBO's fumes, Showtime thinks it may finally have a drama worth talking about. "Huff" stars Hank Azaria as a psychiatrist with more problems than his patients. He's got a racist mother (Blythe Danner), a sexaholic best friend (Oliver Platt) and, when we meet him, a patient who commits suicide in his office. And you thought Tony Soprano had headaches? When network executives introduced the drama to TV writers last July, they trotted out all the standard superlatives. "We think it's spectacular," said Showtime entertainment president Robert Greenblatt. Then Greenblatt did something genuinely impressive: he picked up "Huff" for a second season--even though it wouldn't debut until Nov. 7. There's apparently only one thing standing between "Huff" and success: Paget Brewster. Brewster plays Azaria's wife, though her acting isn't the issue. It's her karma. "When I got 'Huff'," she says, "I thought, 'Well, this poor thing is going to go down in flames now because I'm onboard'."

Brewster is the Red Sox--wait, now it's the Cubs--of TV actresses. She's cursed. After eight years in the business, she's starred in four programs and 16 pilots, all with the half-life of a gnat. Hollywood has a name for such people: show killers. They're actors like Jason Gedrick, late of "Boomtown," who has been on seven failed programs without a hit, and Jon Tenney ("Kristen," "Brooklyn South") who's struck out five times. (To make matters worse, Tenney's ex-wife, Teri Hatcher, is a star of ABC's megahit "Desperate Housewives.") These if-at-first-you-don't-succeed actors sometimes hit pay dirt. Before "ER" George Clooney was known as a "pilot killer," which means his shows were so bad, they never even got on the air. "I'm bad luck," he said 10 years ago. "Don't fly with me." You've got to wonder--where did all these show killers come from? What's it like when your career is partly defined by failure? And how come these people keep getting work?

Before we start getting angry letters from Jon Cryer's father, let's be fair. Television is a collaborative medium. Actors may be the most visible component of a show, but they're hardly alone on the sinking ship. "I've really come to learn it starts with the writing and the schedule," says Marcia Shulman, Fox's head of casting. "I don't believe it's ever the actor's fault." Some Hollywood executives say that the more failed shows an actor does, the better an actor he is. "It's a badge of honor," says Peter Golden, head of casting at CBS and Paramount TV. "An actor who keeps working works for a reason. You believe in him and hope the material is going to be the right fit." Which isn't to say there aren't less charitable reasons that the usual suspects sink year after year. Pretty faces often get hired in inverse proportion to their talent--how else to explain the cast of "Coupling"? Networks also sign holding deals with some actors to keep them from working for rivals. Executives will sometimes hire those actors to justify the investment. "I will give you that there are bad actors," says Golden. "I could definitely see the point of view of the audience who sees the same actor over and over and goes, 'Again?' "

Many actors insist they aren't bothered by the show-killer stigma. Or maybe they really are good actors. "At one point last year when I went for a meeting, I said, 'I just want you to know that I've never been on a show that's lasted for more than 13 episodes'," says Paula Marshall. "It was me making fun of the fact, because it's so not about me and everybody knows it." In La-la Land there are no bad actors, only bad roles (or time slots or directors). …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.