Magazine article American Banker

Ban of Auditor Liability Clauses Considered

Magazine article American Banker

Ban of Auditor Liability Clauses Considered

Article excerpt

Federal regulators are considering whether to ban an increasingly popular liability clause in banks' contracts with their auditors.

Officials at the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. said examiners have noticed clauses in many engagement letters between banks and their outside auditors that limit the auditors' liability in case the bank is accused of accounting violations.

John Lane, the agency's deputy director for risk management, said at a media briefing last week that one reason the clauses have become so popular is that the FDIC and others are increasingly suing auditing firms to recoup losses suffered by their clients as a result of accounting problems.

"I think that that they've seeing an increase in their litigation, and risk of lawsuits, and they're saying how do we limit that," Mr. Lane said. "We see that as a risk to our ability to recover, as receiver, for the insurance fund, for creditors" when a bank fails as a result of such problems.

For example, the FDIC has sued Ernst & Young for $2.2 billion in connection with the failure of Superior Bank FSB of Illinois. A court ruled this year that the FDIC was bound by arbitration clauses in Superior's contract with its auditor.

Steven Fritts, the FDIC's associate director for risk management policy, said the banking and thrift agencies had informally surveyed examiners about the clauses.

"We've seen that there's enough of this, that it's not one isolated thing," he said. "It's occurring with some frequency."

The agencies found about a dozen examples, he said.

One reads: "In no event shall the audit firm be liable for the company for their claim via tort, contract, or otherwise for any consequential, indirect, loss of profit, or similar damages relating to the audit firm's services, except to the extent filing the determined resulted from the willful misconduct or fraudulent behavior of the audit firm. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.