Magazine article The Advocate (The national gay & lesbian newsmagazine)

Wanting Answers

Magazine article The Advocate (The national gay & lesbian newsmagazine)

Wanting Answers

Article excerpt

In the well-observed new film Come Early Morning, Ashley Judd plays an Arkansas woman who confronts her family baggage the only way she knows how: by getting drunk and giving in to it. So sure is she that she could never have a happy relationship that she pushes aside a decent guy (Jeffrey Donovan) who's been trying to introduce her to unfamiliar concepts like foreplay and kissing while sober. After ending up alone again, attempting a preemptive strike against the dysfunction, cheating, and abuse she's seen in her familial interactions, Judd's had enough, and she confronts her pastor, angrily jabbing her finger into the Bible. "I want to know about this," she says. "The sins of the father. Why do I have to carry around shit that's not mine?"

She's not the only one wondering. Several new films this season explore tricky transactions between parent and child, teacher and student, idol and fan. Sure to be among the most controversial of these is The History Boys, which adds a soupcon of illicit sex to the familiar Dead Poets Society formula: Richard Griffiths's Hector is a rotund English teacher who inspires his teen pupils with poetry and analysis and then, at the end of the day, invites them onto his motorbike to discreetly cop a feel.

Conscious of a cultural climate in which priests and congressmen are censured for this sort of thing, The History Boys takes great pains to say, "He ought to know better," but the film's heart isn't really in it. Director Nicholas Hytner (who also helmed the gay-themed The Object of My Affection) seems to see this kind of arrangement as a justified transaction: teachers selflessly bestowing knowledge and demanding only the mildest sexual contact in return. In fact, none of the students seem to mind Hectors fumblings very much, and some actually feel left out when they're not selected for--a false note that reveals exactly how stacked this film's deck is.

Adapted from Alan Bennett's Tony award-winning play, The History Boys eventually overcomes its stagy feel with Oscar-caliber performances and powerful moments late in the game, but it's going to be a hard sell for its studio, Fox Searchlight. The movie has a distinct gay sensibility (the students here would rather reenact scenes from Now, Voyager than listen to the period rock tunes propping up the soundtrack), but at the same time, every gay teacher here lusts after his students--and there are two more introduced besides Hector. At a time when gay people's rights are under attack, not only the right to marry but right to head a classroom, will queer audiences condone the behavior of these teachers as much as the film wants us to?

The new French film Backstage tackles the same issues from another perspective: that of a young girl taken under the wing of a Madonna-like pop star. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.