Magazine article Clinical Psychiatry News

Jury Still out on Viability of Health Courts System

Magazine article Clinical Psychiatry News

Jury Still out on Viability of Health Courts System

Article excerpt

WASHINGTON -- The concept of using administrative law judges instead of civil jury trials to settle malpractice suits has gained some admirers in Congress and generated interest among state legislatures, but it is uncertain whether such a system is the solution to skyrocketing malpractice premiums and jury awards, according to academics, attorneys, and consumer and legislative representatives who met in early November at a meeting sponsored by Common Good and the Harvard School of Public Health, Boston.

Under the "health court" concept, fleshed out earlier this year by Michelle Mello and David Studdert of Harvard, specially trained judges would make compensation decisions according to whether an injury was "avoidable" or "preventable" (Milbank Quarterly 2006;3:459-92). The plaintiff would have to show that the injury would not have happened if best practices were followed. Impartial experts would help set compensation, based on scientific evidence and what is known about avoidability of errors. Decisions would be made quickly.

Such a system would likely increase the number of people eligible for compensation but decrease the size of awards, Ms. Mello said.

Unlike the current tort system, a health court system could also help deter medical errors by collecting data that would then be given back to hospitals and practitioners for root-cause analyses, she explained.

In 2005, Sen. Michael Enzi (R-Wyo.) and Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.) introduced the Fair and Reliable Medical Justice Act (S. 1337), which would provide money for demonstration projects on alternative methods to address malpractice, including health courts. The Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee held a hearing on the bill in June 2006, but there has been no further action.

At the symposium, Stephen Northrup, the health policy staff director for that committee, said it is not clear whether the newly Democratic-controlled Congress will consider alternatives such as health courts. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.