Magazine article Editor & Publisher

Higher Ad-to-Edit Ratio Not a Good Thing?

Magazine article Editor & Publisher

Higher Ad-to-Edit Ratio Not a Good Thing?

Article excerpt

Microsoft's Steve Ballmer can blithely predict that print will be dead in 10 years, but any newspaper operator knows ink on paper is still the lifeline of the industry. Online revenue will not even begin to seriously make up for the revenue shortfall of print for another five or six years down the road, and perhaps not even then.

In the meantime, the name of the game is stanching print advertising losses -- since that revenue still represents more than $45.3 billion (or 90% of the industry). The Newspaper Association of America quietly reported in June that industry print ad revenue in Q1 was down 14.3% to $8.4 billion -- the worst quarterly drop since 1971, when the association started measuring quarterly results.

The pressure bearing down on publishers is immense, but many are now moving to readjust the print product to align with the new realities of the business.

The Sacramento Bee, for example, is cutting its business section and moving it to metro -- one of many changes the California paper is undergoing, according to Editor Melanie Sill.

The Dallas Morning News decided its average daily circulation of about 369,000 just isn't passing muster in a city with a population of about 1.2 million. The company decided the best course of action in reaching more of the Dallas core market is to launch a free home-delivered product. Come August, 200,000 copies of Briefing will land on the doorsteps of non-subscribers Wednesday through Saturday.

And then there's Tribune. The once buttoned-up, now hell-raising group under the new ownership of Sam Zell, announced it would reduce its ad-to-edit ratio to 50/50 by September in order to save money.

Tribune's Chief Operating Officer Randy Michaels explained the strategy on a June 5 conference call. "We decided just as a sort of an arbitrary starting point that a paper looks pretty good at about 50% advertising, and that's ignoring the classifieds or the all-ad sections," he said. "And if you had said there was a minimum number of editorial pages that each of our papers needs to give the consumers what they want and use that as sort of a floor, and then targeted producing 50% editorial content, sitting on a base of the advertising we have now, what you'd find out is that we could take about 500 pages a week -- 500 editorial pages a week -- out of our newspapers and get a 50-50 ad-to-content ratio."

Tribune declined to comment further to E&P on embracing this new strategy.

The Orlando Sentinel is the first paper in the Tribune stable to undergo metamamorphasis. On June 22, the paper's redesign was unveiled to fulfill what the Sentinel had promised: "innovative ways to tell stories, better informational graphics, and more interactivity with readers." The new front page packs more information and teasers in the banner, reducing the size of the flag. It is divided into fewer elements, giving more space and breathing room to stories: Two big boxes contain stories on the top, with two smaller boxes on the bottom (one is an ad).

The Orlando Sentinel was short on details as to how the new look will drive advertising revenue. "Our advertisers will continue to have the opportunity to run their ads in unique, visible places in the paper, such as the front page," John D'Orlando, vice president/ director of advertising, said in a statement. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.