Magazine article Marketing

Mark Kleinman on Marketing and the City: A Heady Cocktail

Magazine article Marketing

Mark Kleinman on Marketing and the City: A Heady Cocktail

Article excerpt

Diageo's 'copycat' case against Sainsbury's will have implications for all brand-owners and retailers.

Fresh fruit, cucumber and a sprig of mint may be the traditional accompaniment to that classic English summer drink, Pimm's, but Sainsbury's encounter with the Diageo brand looks set to prove an altogether more spicy affair.

The supermarket has been hit by a lawsuit from Diageo, the world's biggest alcoholic beverages company, over its Pitchers product, which Diageo alleges is a copycat version of Pimm's. Pitchers, claims Diageo, infringes its intellectual property rights, a charge the supermarket chain denies in the strongest possible terms.

Notwithstanding the apparent similarities between the labels of the two drinks, the legal action may also prove interesting as a renewed litmus test of the appetite of retailers and brand-owners to lock horns in the courts. Given what it may say about the fortunes of either side, shareholders in both businesses are likely to be paying close attention to the outcome.

'We can confirm that we have issued legal proceedings against Sainsbury's in relation to an intellectual property matter,' Diageo stated last week. 'It would be inappropriate to comment further other than to say that Sainsbury's is a valued customer of Diageo and we hope will continue to be so ... It is Diageo's firm intent that our strong trading relationship should not be affected by this discrete dispute.'

Diageo's statement is as revealing for what it does not say as what it does. For much of the past decade, retailers and brand-owners have been embedded in a power struggle that has assumed huge importance for the manufacturers of FMCG brands.

The two sides have been able to work together more closely than was possible in the past, assisted by the availability of detailed sales and customer data that allow more effective NPD and targeted promotions Tesco's acquisition of specialist CRM agency dunnhumby, more than five years ago, is now rightly regarded as one of the smartest acts of the management team assembled by Tesco chief executive Sir Terry Leahy.

Yet there has emerged another, more tense dimension to the relationship, which has sprung from the greater power that has coalesced among the major multiples in recent years. As they have spent millions of pounds building their own-label ranges, many of which now account for a significant proportion of their turnovers, an inevitable friction has arisen between the sides.

In addition, the recession has prompted the tightening of supplier terms by retailers and brand-owners alike. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.