Magazine article Newsweek

The Wrong Scapegoat

Magazine article Newsweek

The Wrong Scapegoat

Article excerpt

Byline: Robert J. Samuelson

Give the Fed its due.

Ever since its creation in 1913, the Federal Reserve has grappled with a daunting political contradiction. The Fed is charged with preventing the collapse of the financial system, whose health is essential for the "real economy" of production and jobs. But financial bailouts usually occur when mistakes or misdeeds by bankers make them public pariahs. To do its job, then, the Fed protects--or seems to protect--an unpopular, disgraced, and undeserving group. We are now witnessing this contradiction in full bloom.

The Fed has become a congressional scapegoat for assorted economic frustrations: 10.2 percent unemployment; expensive rescues of fragile financial institutions; outsize Wall Street bonuses; and the crisis itself. The denunciations transcend rhetorical outbursts. The House Financial Services Committee recently voted to require the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to "audit" the Fed's monetary policy--its efforts to influence interest rates and credit conditions. In the Senate, Christopher Dodd, chairman of the Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee, has proposed stripping the Fed of all powers to regulate financial institutions--its actions to police lending and management practices. These powers would go to a new agency.

Lost in this politically charged climate is the reality that the Fed, more than any other government agency, arguably stopped last fall's financial panic from becoming a global depression. The Fed pumped out more than $1 trillion in new credit, created special lending programs to support faltering segments of the credit markets, and rescued financial institutions, notably AIG, whose bankruptcy might have triggered a chain reaction of failures. These were seat-of-the-pants responses, taken in the midst of crisis and pervasive uncertainty. We will never know what might have happened without them. The -second-guessing now occurs when there's less fear and more information.

What's also overlooked is that the Fed isn't the supersecretive, unaccountable agency of political stereotype. In 2009 Fed officials from chairman Ben Bernanke on down have testified 32 times before congressional committees. The Fed makes detailed disclosures about its policies. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.