Magazine article The Wilson Quarterly

Barnes Storm

Magazine article The Wilson Quarterly

Barnes Storm

Article excerpt

THE SOURCE: "No Museum Left Behind" by Lance Esplund, in The Weekly Standard, May 31, 2010.

MANY IN THE ART WORLD ARE celebrating the Barnes Foundation's relocation from Merion, Pennsylvania, to its new home next to the Philadelphia Museum of Art in 2012 as the long-overdue unlocking of one of the world's premier art collections. But to defenders of the original vision of Albert Coombs Barnes (1872-1951)-and count City Arts senior art critic Lance Esplund firmly among that number--the uprooting is a sacrilege, "no different from the destruction of a Gothic cathedral."

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

The Barnes collection has always excited attention not only because of its scale (conservative appraisals put its worth between $20 billion and $30 billion), but the uniqueness of its arrangement. Barnes eschewed the conventional curatorial approach of hanging art chronologically, or by period or "school," preferring to display his masterpieces on the basis of other similarities--in color, subject matter, technique, or artistic sensibility. A Picasso might hang next to an African mask, or a buxom Renoir nude next to similar works by Rubens or Titian. This is not just an idiosyncratic approach. "It is the way artists look at art," Esplund writes. After a 1930 visit to the Barnes Foundation, the French artist Henri Matisse prophesied that the Barnes aesthetic would "destroy the artificial and disreputable presentation of the other collections."

Matisse proved to be overly optimistic, perhaps because only a select few ever saw the collection. While the mercurial Barnes, who made his fortune in pharmaceuticals, was still alive, students had to demonstrate that they were "in earnest" to gain admission; after his death, it took a lawsuit brought by The Philadelphia Inquirer and its publisher, Walter Annenberg, to force the museum to open to the public in 1961. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.