Magazine article The American Prospect

Race, Gender, and 2012

Magazine article The American Prospect

Race, Gender, and 2012

Article excerpt

If the 2008 election was all about change, then the 2012 race promises to be a referendum on whether things have actually changed. I'm not only talking about Obama's ability to fulfill his campaign promises of a more prosperous, fairer America. I'm also referring to the fact that the last time we elected a president, the candidates who graced the national stage marked a very visible change from previous campaigns. For the first time in history, race and gender did not default to white and male. Identity took center stage. I'm not old enough to remember all that many election cycles, but I'm confident that 2008 was different.

Some observers, myself included, hoped that the groundbreaking 2008 campaign would alter the political landscape forever. That the political parties could no longer win by continuing to nominate only white men. That women and people of color would be better represented in Congress and in the White House. That the various ways race and gender intersect in our society would make for riveting cable-news programming and dinnertable conversation.

It's far too early to predict exactly how the narratives of race and gender will unfold over the course of what will be a two-year campaign. But if the past two years are any indication, 2008 was far from the watershed we'd hoped it would be.

At first, it seemed as if a productive dialogue about race and gender would continue. There were shades of the presidential race when, in 2009, Obama had to make his first nomination to the Supreme Court. Would he choose a woman? A person of color? The answer, of course, was both. Thanks to Senate Republicans, Sonia Sotomayor's confirmation hearings were less about her legal background and her judicial philosophy than they were about her "mean" temperament and comments she'd made about being a Latina. We were still talking about identity, but it was a far cry from the rational dialogue Obama called for in his much-lauded speech about race.

By the 2010 midterm elections, the national conversation about race and gender had taken a turn for the weird. Republicans' favorite campaign narrative was that of the "mama grizzly'--a vaguely feminist label that Sarah Palin first applied to herself and later to every conservative, pro-gun, anti-abortion, anti-tax woman in the running. Just two years after she and other conservative commentators turned up their noses at the "identity politics" of the 2008 Democratic primary, blogger Michelle Malkin touted the "founding mothers" of the Tea Party movement. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.