Magazine article Canadian Dimension

Misogyny on the Bench: No Still Means No Why Feminism Still Matters in 2011

Magazine article Canadian Dimension

Misogyny on the Bench: No Still Means No Why Feminism Still Matters in 2011

Article excerpt

THE FEBRUARY RULING in a sexual assault case in Thompson, Manitoba by Queen's Bench Justice Robert Dewar used victim-blaming rhetoric to justify a two-year conditional sentence for the accused, justice Dewar detailed the survivor's clothing, conduct and attitude on the evening of the assault, stating that "sex was ... more than just a manner of dress, more than the fact that she was a woman. And [that is] a relevant, mitigating factor." Because her attacker may have been misreading her signals, he should be considered a "clumsy Don Juan" rather than a rapist.

Since the story broke, feminists in Winnipeg have been engaged in a constant back-and-forth in the media, fighting a culture that is complicit with the misogyny of this ruling.

This is nothing new for feminists. The Dewar case is a micro version of ongoing conversations we have within our communities about sexual assault. Arguments in defence of Justice Dewar's ruling have included character references from his lawyer pals; pearl-clutching over "girls" who dare to dress as they please and dance in public; comparisons of sexual assault to theft and women's bodies to valuable possessions left in plain view; and countless variations on the argument that if she didn't say the word "no," instead indicating non-consent by stating that she feared for her life, she was giving implicit consent. The "clumsy" rapist was understandably confused, mainstream media commentators tell us.

This dialogue is based on the belief that rape is about sex, and that it happens because women are too arousing and men cannot control their sexuality. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.