Magazine article The Washington Monthly

A Malevolent Forrest Gump: Strom Thurmond's Loathsomeness on Race Obscures His Larger Role: He Was There at All the Major Choke Points of Modern Conservative History

Magazine article The Washington Monthly

A Malevolent Forrest Gump: Strom Thurmond's Loathsomeness on Race Obscures His Larger Role: He Was There at All the Major Choke Points of Modern Conservative History

Article excerpt

Strom Thurmond's America

by Joseph Crespino

Hill and Wang, 416 pp.

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

Like many artists and most bigots, Strom Thurmond was highly productive early in life. By the age of fifty-five, the humorless South Carolina reactionary had run for president as a Dixiecrat, secured election to the U.S. Senate, penned the neo-confederate "Southern Manifesto" denouncing Brown v. Board of Education, and performed the longest one-man filibuster in the Senate's history: a ghastly King Lear with pitchfork and noose, in which Thurmond denounced the 1957 Civil Rights Act as the death of liberty. (It ended when he grew hoarse and sat down.) When Lyndon Johnson pushed the much toothier Civil Rights Act of 1964 through Congress, he again did it over Thurmond's filibuster. The following year, Thurmond fought the Voting Rights Act. His political idols were John C. Calhoun, Robert E. Lee, and Spiro Agnew. In his most famous speech, Thurmond pledged in 1948 that there were not enough troops in the Army to force "the southern people" to "admit the nigger race into our theaters, into our swimming pools, into our homes, and into our churches." But apparently they were allowed into "our" beds: in 1925 the twenty-two-year-old Thurmond sired a child with a sixteen-year-old African American family maid. His illegitimate daughter remained anonymous until her father's death in 2003.

Today Strom Thurmond's name brings to mind two sentiments: revulsion and disgrace. Here was a racist hypocrite who denounced the intermixing of black and white while secretly paying hush money to his own biracial daughter. He never apologized for his years as a segregationist, and even had the nerve later in life to deny that they ever occurred. Thurmond's association was toxic enough to cost Trent Lott his position as Senate majority leader in 2002, when Lott suggested during an unguarded moment that the United States would have been a better place had Thurmond been elected president in 1948.

Yet as Joseph Crespino demonstrates in his outstanding biography, Strom Thurmond's America, it is precisely Thurmond's loathsomeness on racial issues that obscures his larger role in American politics. Like some malevolent Forrest Gump, Thurmond was there at all the major choke points of modern conservative history: the 1948 breakaway from the Democrats of the short-lived States' Rights Democratic (or Dixiecrat) Party, Barry Goldwater's 1964 presidential campaign, Richard Nixon's southern strategy in 1968, and Ronald Reagan's ascendance in 1980. A Democrat until 1964, Thurmond was the fulcrum on which the parties traded places on race issues. His trademark use of nasty populism dressed up in constitutional principle has echoes today on the far right--the territory of Rush Limbaugh and the shrillest of the Tea Partiers. Yet he also helped cement the association between conservatives on the one hand and big business, the Christian right, and anticommunism on the other.

Crespino, a history professor at Emory University, presents the right blend of narrative, scholarly analysis, and restrained outrage, reminding readers that Thurmond cared about far more than segregation. In 1957 the liberal group Americans for Democratic Action gave him the lowest score of any Democrat in the Senate: a zero. As Crespino writes, "Thurmond was the first southerner in the postwar period to bring together on a regional scale the visceral politics of white supremacy with southern business and industrial opposition to the New Deal." Thurmond sat on the board of trustees of Bob Jones University, loathed communists, and never met a weapons program he didn't like. As South Carolina's governor from 1947 to 1951, he developed a talent for attracting companies to his state, trading his early pro-labor bona tides for reflexive hostility to unions. In 1962, the Kennedy administration incensed him by "muzzling" military leaders who had forced their troops to read material from the John Birch Society and other far-right groups. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.