Magazine article Marketing

Centre Stage

Magazine article Marketing

Centre Stage

Article excerpt

Former CEO AG Lafley's unexpected return to Procter & Gamble signals change, and a glimpse of its former stability; but how will it affect the company's brand marketing strategies, asks Ben Bold.

When Procter & Gamble announced a month ago that its former chief executive, AG Lafley, was returning after four years' retirement to retake the helm from chief executive Bob McDonald, Wall Street reacted with surprise. However, it received a warm response, which differed markedly from the litany of analysts' complaints that have blighted McDonald's troubled tenure at the FMCG company.

A P&G spokesman insisted that McDonald has simply chosen to step back after 33 years of service, having made 'substantial progress' in the top job; others are far more scathing. So what went wrong for the business, home to brands from Max Factor to Ariel, under his stewardship?

'Bob didn't move the game on from the AG days and brought nothing new to the party,' says Simon Michaelides, marketing director at UKTV and a former P&G marketer under Lafley's previous regime, which lasted from 2000 to 2009. 'In terms of personality, he lacked dynamism by comparison and had no rallying cry for the organisation.'

Such damning sentiments echo the criticisms of many commentators, who have attacked McDonald for focusing too much on high-end innovation. 'He also decided to go after low-return investments in emerging markets (where there was already strong competition from other more established players),' adds Ali Dibadj, an analyst at US research firm Sanford C Bernstein.

Under McDonald, P&G last year embarked on an unsuccessful bid to cut dollars 1bn from its dollars 10bn global marketing spend by shifting focus onto social sites and earned media. Reports subsequently emerged that P&G had been hit by Facebook's algorithm change, meaning its brands were unable to reach their entire audience via the network.

Since Lafley rejoined P&G on 23 May, he has already announced a restructure that will split the company's two business units into four, a move he claims will 'help (P&G) get closer to the consumer and become more agile with customers'.

Each of the global divisions - baby, feminine and family care; beauty; health and grooming; and fabric and home care - will be led by a senior P&G executive, one of whom, it is widely expected, will eventually succeed Lafley as chief executive. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.