Magazine article The Christian Century

Fights over Gay Marriage Are Just Getting Started

Magazine article The Christian Century

Fights over Gay Marriage Are Just Getting Started

Article excerpt

The Supreme Court decisions on gay marriage, while historic, didn't settle the issue. In fact, they fuel it.

For President Obama, the repercussions of the June 26 ruling striking down part of the Defense of Marriage Act will mean review and revisions for hundreds of federal laws. In everything from Social Security checks to Pentagon benefits, gay married couples now must be treated the same way as heterosexual couples.

For gay rights advocates, the accompanying decision, which opened the door to resume same-sex marriages in California, bolstered determination to expand the right to wed for gay men and lesbians. The Human Rights Campaign set a goal to achieve that right in all 50 states within the next five years.

And for opponents of gay marriage, the battle turned to state capitols, where 36 states bar gay marriage by statute or constitutional amendment. "We didn't lose," Brian Brown of the National Organization for Marriage said, noting the high court had declined to recognize a constitutional right to marry. "They punted."

The two decisions were undeniably far-reaching, clearing the way for gay marriages to resume in the nation's largest state and striking down a federal law that barred the government from recognizing same-sex marriages sanctioned by states. But previous landmark court decisions on divisive issues, including racial integration and abortion rights, have prompted decades of legal and political fights over their meaning and implementation, not to mention efforts to reverse them.

"The good side of this ruling is that they have affirmed to states that this is a state issue and states can decide," Sen. Rand Paul (R., Ky.), said on Glenn Beck's radio show. He counseled allies: "The battle is going to be lost at the federal level. Concentrate on your state."

"With these two historic rulings, we've taken two giant steps forward toward the American promise of equal justice under law," Chad Griffin, president of the HRC, said in an interview. "We celebrate today, and tomorrow we wake up and fight like hell."

Attorney General Eric Holder promised that the administration would work "expeditiously" to implement the changes in laws and benefits stemming from the demise of DOMA. "Important, life-changing work remains before us," he said.

In the second case, the challenge to California's Proposition 8 banning gay marriage, the court's narrow ruling--that the supporters of the ban didn't have the standing to bring the case--doesn't affect other states. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.