Magazine article The Christian Century

The Ecology of Spirituality: Meanings, Virtues, and Practices in a Post-Religious Age

Magazine article The Christian Century

The Ecology of Spirituality: Meanings, Virtues, and Practices in a Post-Religious Age

Article excerpt

The Ecology of Spirituality: Meanings, Virtues, and Practices

in a Post-Religious Age

By Lucy Bregman

Baylor University Press, 198 pp.,

$29.95 paperback

I once walked 500 miles of Spain's famous Camino de Santiago. Some 200,000 pilgrims now traverse this enormously popular route each year. Only a small fraction go for traditional religious reasons such as prayer, penance, and solitude; far more participate for the physical challenge, as an economical vacation, for a long-distance hike in good company, or for spiritual reasons other than traditional Christian motivations.

As I walked beside, listened to, and shared bandages and meals with seekers from around the world, I was impressed over and over again by how earnestly my companions were searching for deep, authentic ways of living. I came away from the journey less dismissive of folks who label themselves spiritual but not religious. I am convinced that Christians have much to learn from them and that we will remain foggy about our own Good News until we do.

Temple University religion professor Lucy Bregman looks at the rapidly evolving term spirituality and notes that the word is used to suggest many things: "the depth and truth and all-inclusive wholeness of life, our lost and lamented connection to the universe," "yearning for wholeness," life orientation, meaning and purpose. It has become an "enormous umbrella-like category believed by many to be intrinsically resistant to definition." At the same time, traditional religious practices such as meditation and yoga are routinely offered and consumed in ways completely divorced from their original religious structures, becoming "spiritual techniques" or "wisdom technologies."

These current meanings of spirituality have nothing to do with the spiritual or the spirit, let alone the Holy Spirit, but Bregman does not write them off. She wants to find out what "makes spirituality so appealing." She recognizes that there is "something positive, something worth discovering, behind all the usages of spirituality today," but she is also wary of the "enormous fascination and the heady glow," the "utopian aura," the tales "of liberation and hope," and the strange "blend of hopefulness and confusion."

A standard 1983 definition of spirituality that Bregman cites refers to "those aspects of a person's ... faith commitment that concern ... striving to attain the highest ideal or goal." This involves decision and deliberation, as well as practicing within a particular tradition. Bregman notes that "living a faith or a commitment requires long-term dedication over time, a set of beliefs about that commitment, and a community and tradition that supports individuals in their aims. All of this occurs in a historical setting that cannot be ignored or severed from the life of faith."

Today spirituality is often tied to pursuing high ideals but seldom linked to religious traditions or institutions. It now tends to be about a basic "human core" that belongs to everyone, rather than about choice or conscious deliberation. It is "one-poled," speaking only of "the inner-depth dimensions of human nature" and excluding "explicit references to the cosmos as a whole or anything beyond or outside ourselves. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.