Magazine article The Christian Century

Judge Rules Controversial Ad Is Allowed on NYC Transit

Magazine article The Christian Century

Judge Rules Controversial Ad Is Allowed on NYC Transit

Article excerpt

A federal judge in Manhattan ordered the Metropolitan Transportation Authority to display a controversial ad from a pro-free-speech group on buses.

The MTA declined to run the ad last year, saying that its message could incite violence. But U.S. District Court judge John Koeltl ruled April 21 that the ad qualified as protected speech and granted a preliminary injunction ordering that the transportation authority run it.

The advertisement is paid for by the American Freedom Defense Initiative and was meant to parody a campaign by the Council on American Islamic Relations called My Jihad. CAIR's website states that the My Jihad campaign aims to "take back Islam from Muslim and anti-Muslim extremists alike." The AFDI ad, meanwhile, shows a man wearing a scarf around his head. A quote to the man's right attributed to "Hamas MTV" says, "Killing Jews is worship that draws us close to Allah." Below the quote the ad reads: "That's His Jihad. What's yours?"

MTA officials said that the ad could be misinterpreted as a call to violence against Jews and thus could be banned by an exception to the First Amendment that restricts speech inciting imminent violence.

In his ruling, Koeltl said that "there is no evidence that seeing one of these advertisements on the back of a bus would be sufficient to trigger a violent reaction. Therefore, these ads--offensive as they may be--are still entitled to First Amendment protection."

Civil liberties scholars largely agree that the court's decision is in line with First Amendment law.

"The city also argued that there was a risk of vandalizing or attacking the buses, but the court said there is no real evidence," said Eugene Volokh, professor of First Amendment law at UCLA's School of Law. "That is something most courts would agree on."

The Southern Poverty Law Center and the Anti-Defamation League have labeled the AFDI as promoting "anti-Islam hate." But First Amendment lawyers point out that no matter how controversial the group's message, it cannot be legally banned.

"There is a very strong principle in First Amendment law that protects against viewpoint discrimination," said Vincent Blasi, Corliss Lamont Professor of Civil Liberties at Columbia Law School. "When a message is directed at a general audience, it is protected."

He contrasted such speech with speech directed at specific people.

"If you are singling out a person or identifiable group, usually one of two things could lead to that being restricted: it's done as a form of personal harassment or stalking, or it's a sensitive environment, for example, in a classroom," he said. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.