Magazine article Diverse Issues in Higher Education

Cashing in? Higher Ed Institutions Struggle with the Issue of Keeping Revenue-Generating Sports That Are Not Producing a Profit

Magazine article Diverse Issues in Higher Education

Cashing in? Higher Ed Institutions Struggle with the Issue of Keeping Revenue-Generating Sports That Are Not Producing a Profit

Article excerpt

When The University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) announced June 1 that there would be gridiron games this fall, many around the country were perplexed--and many others thrilled by the obvious victory for the sport that is a way of life in Alabama.

The announcement came six months after President Ray Watts declared the end of the program. Keeping football on campus, it was decided then, was too expensive and took too much away from the rest of the campus--67 percent of the $30 million budget came from the university's school funds and student fees. This was also a school in one of the smaller Football Bowl Subdivision conferences, Conference USA.

Watts said that, after hiring a consultant, who projected that fielding a competitive team would cost $49 million over the next five years, "there was no way for us to cover that unless we took away from education and research and health care."

But after rallying cries from students, alumni and the Birmingham community, the school caved and announced it would field a team for the 2015 season after all.

And so, the team will return to the field in a conference in which a school cannot compete in any sport if it does not field a football team. The university will cap subsidies from the general fund at $14.49 million for each of the next five years ($200,000 less than the 2015 subsidy amount) and the City of Birmingham, UAB's National Alumni Society and the student government have all pledged to do their parts to chip in to make up the difference.

Football 1, university budgets 0

UAB is not alone in this quandary over athletics.

According to Dr. Earl Smith, professor emeritus of sociology at Wake Forest University who has focused largely on the sociology of sport throughout his career, "It is a commonly held myth that the so-called 'revenue-generating sports' of football and men's basketball make a profit and even pay for the other 'lesser' sports like women's softball, volleyball, and track and field. Though some sports generate revenue, very few ... generate profit."

In fact, of the 128 Division I football programs, only seven finish debt-free year after year, according to the Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics.

"At the nation's most prominent universities, intercollegiate athletics have always played a dual role in campus life," according to a Knight Commission report. "On the one hand, they are managed for the benefit of student-athletes. On the other, they inspire the interest and passions of thousands, if not millions, of fans. For most teams at most institutions, these roles can be reconciled. But in high-profile sports, tensions often surface between the core mission of universities and commercial values."

Smith says that, in many cases, athletics drive the bus at schools classified for their research and scholarship.

"Faculty members, who are the primary drivers of the commodity that is produced in colleges and universities--an education --have salaries that pale in comparison to athletic staff, go years without raises and yet are the very labor power that keeps the student-athletes academically eligible," he says. "Many campuses are in serious need of upgrading their facilities, particularly modernizing classrooms with the technology necessary to effectively deliver education."

"Nevertheless, the pursuit of those elusive goals [of fielding a team whose television revenues and ticket sales generate enough money for the program to profit] by many programs creates a cost spiral that causes athletics spending to rise at rates often exceeding those on academic spending," continued the report. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.